Would you trust AI with your investment portfolio?
Posted on 26th February 2024
Every finance professional has been there.
You have a wealth of knowledge built from a career in your specialism – but that doesn’t stop friends and relatives seeing you as a personal Martin Lewis, able to answer everything from what to expect in the upcoming Budget to why their high street bank has now become a Starbucks.
Finance fatigue may well be creeping into your social life, but switching off your money brain as soon as you down tools doesn’t necessarily help your personal financial health. You know you need to explore you own personal investments, but it all seems like a lot of work…
So, what does the savvy personal investor who doesn’t want to spend hours trawling the markets do these days? Unsurprisingly, as ever, the answer lies with tech.
i-Robot
Robo investing is the AI of personal investing. Automated platforms help decide where best to place your capital for the best return, with complex systems using intelligent algorithms to manage diversified portfolios. Decisions are made based on your own pre-set risk tolerance, with no need for any human intervention (except making the initial deposit, of course)!
Most platforms offer either a conservative or aggressive portfolio option, catering for either the risk adverse, or those who fancy a slightly wilder ride. The systems leverage diversification in order to manage risk against your pre-set risk profile, something you have full control of.
As with all investments, it is important to note that regardless of the lightening-fast reaction speed of a robo investor application, ROI is always influenced by the market, with no guaranteed returns.
Investing in technology
Whilst there is no human input, which brings the cost down significantly, there is still a price to pay to harness the power of the robot brain.
Most robo investment platforms change a management fee, which ranges from 0.25 % to 0.75% of the assets under management.
Levels of control
The system is designed for you to put your trust in the algorithms, and as such, there’s little input from the user. The platforms have been designed to be as user-friendly as possible, making them popular with novice investors, and those who want a more hands-off approach, but this may be off-putting for anyone used to getting a little more involved.
This can be fine if you’re asking AI to write you a song, or design you an image, but juggle with your hard-earned cash? That’s a bigger ask.
What are the risks?
If you’ve ever engaged with Alexa or Siri, you’ll appreciate that the technology isn’t always flawless… AI is an incredible feat of modern engineering, but it’s not yet without its flaws, and that’s a risk when it comes to handing over cold, hard cash.
Technical hiccups and cybersecurity threats are also potentials when it comes to our technical friends, which could add a layer of risk into your investing portfolio.
In a nutshell, AI or stick with the traditional?
If you’re looking to invest millions, it is possible that you might not want to hang your hat on the hook of robo investing. When talking about large amounts of money, an element of personal involvement still ranks highly on the list.
That said, as a simple option for small investment portfolios, there’s an argument for letting AI take the reins, and of course, it’s a great way to simplify the process, and make it accessible to the younger generation.
Some firms also now offer a hybrid option, giving you the opportunity to make the most of the robot tech, but also have the security of a human hand to hold along the way too.
There has been plenty in the press about robo investing, so much in fact that you may be querying whether there is even a market for a good old-fashioned human investment professional. Well, rest assured, robots haven’t replaced human advisors just yet! Whilst the pandemic certainly had an impact on face-to-face interactions, human advisors offer a suite of very different solutions, and the digital options doesn’t suit everyone – there’s certainly room in the market for both.
A recent study by Vanguard looked at the value of both options to investors. The research used both qualitative and quantitative methods to understand how and why investors choose human versus digital advice services and the tasks that define each service model.
The study suggested that before a decision is made, an investor should weigh up both the financial and emotional value of a portfolio (explained via a framework outlined by Pagliaro and Utkus (2019)):
The framework includes:
- Portfolio value, activities such as asset allocation, diversification, rebalancing, and performance.
- Financial value including establishing goals, saving and spending strategies, debt management, retirement, and estate planning.
- Emotional value including trust and confidence in your adviser, peace of mind that you will achieve your goals, and assurance in times of market volatility.
Using this framework, the research then revealed that investors believe that human-advised clients derive more emotional value from advice than digital-advised clients get from theirs – with human advisors offering a 40% portfolio, 35% financial value and 25% emotional value. Robo investors, on the other hand, offer 47% on portfolio value, 35% on financial value and only 18% on emotional value.
This emotional connection was further reinforced further into the research, when the 1,518 participants surveyed stated that:
- 68% had trust in the advice given by a human advised service, compared to only 18% using a digital service.
- 63% felt a human-advised service understood their financial plan and/or goals well, compared to just 22% using a digital service.
- Only 22% of digital users felt that they were being supported into taking the level of risk that is right for them, compared with 61% of human-advised customers who felt encouraged to stay within their set parameters.
The research concluded that many of the functional tasks relating to portfolio management can be slickly automated with robo investing, but agree that human advisors top the list when it comes to delivering emotional support.
So, if you are looking for a hands-off, formulaic, unemotional transaction, robo investing could still be right for you. But if you are looking for something a little more involved, and possibly even a little advice… according to Vanguard and their research, you still need to explore the traditional route.