The Right to Disconnect: Implications for UK Finance Sector
Posted on 22nd August 2024
As the UK inches closer to adopting the “right to disconnect,” a policy already implemented in several European countries, leaders are urged to assess its potential impact on organisations, both positive and negative.
The ‘Right to Disconnect’ grants employees the legal ability to disengage from all work-related communications outside of their official working hours. For many finance professionals, this could mean a shift in how work-life boundaries are managed.
Following the announcement of the policy, the prime minister’s spokesperson said the proposal was intended to ensure that ‘we’re not inadvertently blurring the lines between work and home life.’
They added: ‘One of the central missions of the government is for growth and we know that productivity is vital to growth.’
Sounds great, in principle, but experts are urging businesses to consider that this may not be all positive, for organisations or employees… with the policy promised as part of the Employment Rights Bill, it is crucial for businesses to understand both the opportunities and challenges this legislation could bring.
Potential impacts
Organisations in the finance sector operate in a highly demanding environment, where working outside standard hours can feel like standard practice. With emails on your phone and working from home meaning you are never truly away from ‘the office’, it can be increasingly difficult to properly switch off.
This legislation could redefine this issue, potentially boosting employee wellbeing but at the same time posing operational challenges – after all, we have all got used to the 24/7 accessibility that technology affords.
So, what are the benefits for organisations?
- Productivity: Research suggests that clear work-life boundaries can lead to employees that are feeling the benefit of a good work/life balance, ultimately enhancing productivity.
- Less slips: Refreshed employees could mean less tiredness-induced slip-ups… is it possible that a ban on out of hours contact could mean fewer mistakes and better decision-making?
- Cost Management: With plenty of economic pressures currently facing businesses, every manager understands the additional squeeze associated with employee burnout. By helping reduce this, not only are you looking at a happier and healthier workforce, but you’re also looking at a far healthier bottom line.
And the challenges?
- Flexibility: Organisations often require staff to be available outside typical hours, especially during critical periods like audits, year-end, or market fluctuations. The right to disconnect may limit this flexibility, complicating client service and responsiveness.
- Culture: Enforcing a disconnect policy could disrupt the culture within firms where (rightly or wrongly) long hours are sometimes seen as a commitment to client success and career progression. Rewriting this long-established rule book overnight may be a tricky task.
- Implementation: ON paper, the task is simple -don’t contact colleagues outside of working hours. However, implementing this rule when we have been so used to round-the-clock responsivity may be easier said than done. It’s likely that there may be some burnt fingers as a result of mismanagement of the policy, rather than any malicious intent during the bedding in process.
No ‘one size fits all’
Clearly, the policy is a very generic, after all, the government are designing legislation for every working person in the UK.
However, unlike some other industries, money never sleeps, and concerns have been raised by organisations within the financial sector how the potential new rules might impact the market. If an international bank has a hiccup in Honk Kong, chances are their counterparts in London are going to want to be made aware straight away, rather than waiting until 9am the following day to be notified of the potential headache.
Ben Willmott, head of public policy at the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), the professional body for HR, said: ‘It’s important that any new right to switch off is introduced with sufficient flexibility to enable employers to contact employees outside normal working hours where unforeseen circumstances require.
‘There will be different demands for this type of flexibility depending on the sector and the nature of people’s jobs, which would need to be recognised in the code of practice.
‘Employers will need to ensure they have clear policies aligned to any new code, clarifying circumstances where managers can and cannot contact staff outside usual working hours’.
Sir Keir Starmer’s spokesperson said that the government’s plans were not a ‘one size fits all’ and would recognise companies vary and people have different roles.