The art of the interview: A two-way street
Posted on 7th January 2025
‘Tis the season to be interviewing!
The Christmas decorations are packed away, desks are groaning with healthy snacks and recruitment teams are frantically fielding requirements for new hires.
But with the excitement of new team members comes the pressure of interviewing. Of course, it’s no walk in the park for the candidate, but for many interviewers, it’s not necessarily a great experience either.
Best foot forwards
With a line of top talent to meet with, it may seem that it is just a case of undertaking due diligence on candidate’s CV’s, figuring out who would gel best with the existing team and settling in for a day of decision making?
Possibly not… an interview is an opportunity for both parties to put their best foot forwards and sell their positives. Employees are increasingly encouraged to ‘bring their whole selves to work’, so it is no surprise that interviews are becoming a location in which candidates are encouraged to probe their interviewer to figure out if their personal values really align with that of the organisation, or whether their ‘whole self’ is going to jar with that of the brand, and potentially their colleagues.
Leaving a bad taste
So, what if it all goes awry during the interview and the interviewee leaves a negative impression? Could an unintentional hiccup with someone who doesn’t yet work at the company really leave a lasting smear on the entire organisation?
Potentially so. A poor reputation can follow a company, with websites like Glassdoor making poor hiring processes public. Whether it’s an unnecessarily lengthy hiring process, and interviewer’s poor timekeeping or an series of awkwardly probing questions, you can be sure that if an interviewee is left scalded, the incident may turn up on the company’s digital stamp. Not only do reviews like this reflect badly on the organisation’s brand immediately, but they can also have a real impact on whether future talent will bother applying at all.
Legal risk
There is also the very real risk of legal ramifications if an interview is not handled properly. There are some very clear guidelines around what you can and can’t ask in an interview. Any questions that directly or indirectly relate a protected characteristics as outlined in the Equality Act – namely age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage or civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation – are an absolute no-no for interview.
A candidate cannot be judged on any of the protected characteristics, and if an interviewer is considered to be asking questions or making assumptions based on them, they could find themselves in very hot legal water.
On-the-spot’ questions
If you were a biscuit, what would you be? How many hairdressers are there in the UK? What’s the diving speed of a Peregrine Falcon? The joy of a random question during an interview.
Sure, they might have the exact answer (Chocolate Hobnob, 121,500 and 200 mph, if you’re curious), but it is unlikely that their biscuit choice is going to help you determine whether an individual is going to slot seamlessly into your existing team. All the question is likely to do is put the interviewee on the spot, get them flustered and leave them feeling negative about the process.
But when it’s done well?
It’s essential for organisations to prioritise professionalism, respect, and fairness during the interview process. The finance sector is highly competitive, and candidates are working hard to make it to interview stage, so it is important that the effort to reach this stage is recognised.
By the time a candidate sits down in an interview, you can be sure that they will have done plenty of due diligence on the organisation and be confident that it is somewhere that they could see themselves excelling.
As the first interaction with a front-line team member, the interviewee is the first opportunity they have to gauge how they may fit within an existing team, and whether the assumptions they have made about the company culture are correct.
Whether the candidate is the right fit for the organisation or not, extending a warm welcome and remaining encouraging throughout can really help the interview remain a positive experience, enhancing the company’s reputation and potentially leading to a larger pool of qualified candidates in the future.