Testing times: How candidate testing has become a standard step in the recruitment process
Posted on 4th April 2024
We all know that to land your perfect role, you have to tick all the right boxes when it comes to the perfect set of skills.
It’s not always just about ‘on-paper’ skills though.
More and more employers are looking to ensure that a candidate’s personality is a perfect fit for their organisational culture, as well as their CV ticking the boxes.
Increasingly, testing – both aptitude and psychometric – is being used as a tool to assess both the ability and the personality traits of an individual, to see how they may sit alongside existing team members, as well as within the business itself.
Ensuring the correct person is hired is important for all parties – employee, employer and existing team members. A simple set of tests can help ensure that the final decision is the right one, which has a positive long-term impact for all.
Types of testing
In general, all tests fall into two broad categories. There are those designed to assess measures of typical performance, and those designed to explore more personality-based elements.
Measures of performance usually consist of questions with right and wrong answers, or tasks that can be performed better or worse. Tests designed to assess personality have no right or wrong answers – instead, they measure how much of a specific personality trait someone possesses.
Both types of testing can be used in recruitment functions, with high-level roles often requiring candidates to undertake a series of tests before or after interview. Similar testing can also be used in both an educational and clinical setting, offering intelligence for diagnosis.
Performance-based tests
They are likely to include questions that relate to logic and reasoning, with many of these measuring characteristics such as intellectual ability, verbal fluency, working memory, numerical reasoning, clerical speed and accuracy, spelling and programming aptitude.
These tests generally have both correct and incorrect answers, although they are not designed to test your knowledge, rather to understand your ability.
You could expect them to be broken down into topics such as:
- Verbal reasoning: This helps determine your ability to absorb and process written information, and make an informed decision based on the information you are provided with.
- Numerical reasoning: Extracting data from a combination of written and numerical data, often presented in charts, reports and graphs, your mathematical problem-solving skills will be tested.
- Inductive reasoning: This assessment looks at your ability to identify patterns and trends in data, when displayed in various forms.
- Spatial reasoning: the ability to understand and interpret spatial relations between objects.
- Logical reasoning: You may be asked to provide a logical conclusion to a question or situation, based on data provided in the test.
- Working memory: The ability to retain information while using it to perform a task.
This sort of test has been developed from classical IQ testing, which can be traced all the way back to Sir Francis Galton, cousin of Charles Darwin in the late 1800s. Galton’s passion for showcasing people’s individual differences led him to develop a system that allowed objective testing to provide a meaningful score.
Galton’s theory was further developed in 1890 by James Cattel, a professor of psychology at the University of Pennsylvania and Columbia, who’s research suggested that simple mental tests could be used to measure intelligence. He developed a series of ten tests designed to measure reaction times, least noticeable difference, colour naming ability, accuracy, judgement, memory and attention spans of students.
These initial learnings were crystallised a few years later by French psychologist Alfred Binet and his colleague, Theodore Simon. The pair developed a series of questions that focused on areas unrelated to intelligence, such as memory and problem-solving, eventually coming up with a 30-question test, which became knowns as the Binet-Simon Scale, the first recognised IQ test.
Psychometric tests
Psychometric tests can be used to help predict a candidate’s behaviour within an occupational context. Employers can then make a more informed choice about a candidate’s character traits and how they fit within the business.
They are designed to analyse an individual’s thinking process, taking into account personality traits, integrity and emotional intelligence.
There are no set correct answers for questions used in this type of testing, they require less preparation, and there is usually no time limit. A candidate simply has to answer honestly and give a good representation of their performance in each given situation – often this can be a little nerve-wracking as it may raise concerns that answering honestly may hinder chances of securing the role… however it needn’t cause panic!
Here are some of our top tips for personality-based psychometric testing:
- Be yourself – there are no right answers, and what might be a desirable response for one employer may not be for another. The best you can do is answer honestly.
- Don’t try to second guess – there is no way to predict what a recruiter really wants. Stay focused on your own answers and motivations throughout, and don’t be tempted to say what you think a recruiter wants to hear.
- Don’t panic – psychometric tests won’t be enough to win or lose you a job alone. They help inform an employer how you’d fit into the company, and build a profile of your personality.
- See the bigger picture: tests are meant to help sell yourself to an employer, they never work in isolation. Make sure you’re just as prepared for the rest of the interview as you are for any potential questions which may arise.
- And, most importantly, relax. Psychometric tests needn’t be anything to worry about.
Whilst there are a number of personality-based testing variants, with the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) one of the most famous.
The test was developed by Isabel Briggs-Myers and her mother Katherine Briggs during World War Two, in order to help women find employment roles that best suited their strengths whilst men were deployed on the front line.
The basis of the test is formed around Carl Jung’s theory of four archetypal personality types – the persona (how we present to the world), the shadow (our repressed ideas and weaknesses), the anima/animus (or masculine/feminine features), and the self (unified conscious and unconscious). The Myers-Briggs model expanded on this theory, suggesting that the test could reliably assess a candidate and place them in one of 16 brackets. The brackets help identify strengths and weaknesses, likes and dislikes and how well you may interact with others of different brackets.
Do tests always give a clear picture?
It is fair to say it is not possible to get a 360° view of someone’s entire personality simply by asking them to answer a few questions. Whilst testing may give a little more insight, you cannot expect them to deliver a complete picture, and experts have warned against an over-reliance on test results as a decision-swayer. However, coupled with a series of interviews and possibly even conversations with references, they do help build another dimension.
Everyone who undertakes a test will have a slightly different picture – even if they have a very similar background. But this is exactly what the system is designed to highlight. Tests are designed to show up differences between people, but similarly they should not highlight differences where differences do not exist or fail to show differences that do exist.
- Fair and unbiased: Tests must not put any individual at a disadvantage, and personal differences should not create bias in test reporting.
- Reliable: a candidate needs to be confident that the measurements of a test are accurate.
- Valid: a test score must demonstrate a meaningful measure of the qualities that the test was designed to assess.
- Standardised: Conversions from ‘test scores’ to ‘test results’ must always follow a standardised format, following pre-agreed norms.
- Objective – The results must not be impacted by the assessors own beliefs.
The Psychological Testing Centre (PTC), part of the British Psychological Society recommends in its test users guide that: ‘Tests should be supported by evidence of reliability and validity for their intended purpose. Evidence should be provided to support the inferences that may be drawn from the scores on the test.’