No income tax, no VAT: Small business tax evasion costs the UK billions
Posted on 11th September 2024
The National Audit Office (NAO) has revealed that business tax evasion in the UK cost an estimated £5.5 billion for the 2022-2023 financial year.
According to the NAO, small firms account for 80% of these losses, and the problem has been growing each year.
The situation has deteriorated since 2011, when online registration for companies through Companies House became available, including for businesses from overseas, with the NAO criticising HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) for lacking a focused strategy to combat this issue. While stricter registration rules at Companies House did take effect in March 2024, the NAO don’t think this has done enough to tackle the issue, and that additional measures, such as verifying the identities of company directors, are still needed.
The NAO’s report highlights that the UK government is missing out on billions of pounds annually due to small retail businesses exploiting system weaknesses to evade taxes – money that everyone would prefer was going into the joint pot, especially with the new Chancellor’s nerve-wracking budget on the horizon…
The organisation warns that retail chains have become adept at expanding rapidly, paying minimal taxes, and then becoming insolvent without settling their tax debts, leaving the government financially disadvantaged and the taxpayer footing the bill.
Small businesses were responsible for 81% of the £5.5 billion lost to tax evasion in 2022-2023, a significant increase from 66% in 2019-2020. Despite HMRC’s efforts to target specific sectors like sweet shops and takeaways, the NAO suggests that success is unlikely until new safeguards from Companies House are fully implemented. The Labour Party, prior to the election, pledged to tackle ‘dodgy’ businesses, including those common in ‘high-traffic’ areas like London’s Oxford Street (and Peckham market, of course)!
Retailers have been engaging in practices like electronic sales suppression (ESS), where they process payments without declaring them, often using methods like dummy accounts or operating tills in training mode. These businesses then declare bankruptcy to evade tax debts and reappear under different names, a practice known as phoenixism. This scheme alone accounted for 15% of HMRC’s tax debt losses in 2022-2023, translating to over £500 million.
The Insolvency Service reported only seven disqualifications for phoenixism between 2018-2019 and 2023-2024 out of a total of 6,274 disqualified directors. Tax Justice UK criticised HMRC for being underfunded and hampered by outdated IT systems, which have undermined its ability to tackle tax fraud effectively.
Sara Hall, Deputy Director for External Affairs at Tax Justice UK said: ‘It is no wonder that billions of pounds of tax is evaded each year.
‘Providing the tax office with the resources it needs will enable it to collect significant sums that can help repair public finances and invest in the NHS, local councils and the key services we all rely on’.
Gareth Davies, the head of the NAO, accused HMRC of lacking an ‘effective strategic response’ to small business tax evasion, saying: ‘Its (HMRC’s) assessment of risks has given too little emphasis to widely used methods of evasion such as sales suppression and phoenixism. It has also failed to use new powers to tackle tax evasion.
‘Tackling tax evasion is not a straightforward task. But real opportunities exist for HMRC to work more systematically across government to reduce it. Tighter controls and more compliance work could raise significant sums and improve value for money’.
The NAO’s report concludes that while tighter registration requirements are a step forward, more comprehensive measures are essential to address the ongoing issues with tax evasion and improve the effectiveness of tax collection.