Automated Push Payment scams

The UK’s City minister Bim Afolami has received a strongly worded letter from 30 members of the Payments Association, in a challenge to the upcoming change in fraud repayment rules – and he seems to be in full agreement.

His response was that he agreed that the new rules posed ‘significant problems’.

The rules, designed by the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR), are due to come into play in October, and plan to force firms to reimburse victims of fraud, setting a maximum reimbursement at up to £415,000.

Organisations are arguing that this hefty figure could damage smaller fintechs and are pushing for the refund figure to instead be set at £30,000 – a number closer to the average consumer loss.

Criminal activity

With financial crime making up 40% of criminal activity in the UK, it is clear that something has to be done to tackle the issue and improve the situation for victims. Authorised Push Payment (APP) fraud a particular concern, with scams costing the UK over £240million in losses in the first half of 2023.

Of course, the ideal solution is to stop fraud at its source. The government has allocated £400m to tackle the issue and is deploying 400 dedicated officers too. However, with banks like TSB suggesting that 80% of fraud is originating on social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram and Whatsapp, there is only so thin that 400 police officers can spread themselves… There are also concerns that savvy fraudsters may pose as victims to recoup compensation, with the regulations unwillingly creating a whole new type of fraud.

There has been much debate over who is fully responsible for the cost of these digitally originating losses, with banks campaigning for tech companies to start putting their hands in their (very deep) pockets and paying their share too. Currently, the regulations only apply to banks and payment service providers including building societies, e-money companies, remittance services and credit card issuers. 

Upcoming changes

Currently, repayment figures vary widely between banks. The PSR has found that some organisations currently refund more than 90% of victims and others just 10%. The new rules, due to come into force on 7th October, would split the cost between the institutions sending and receiving the scam payment. The suggested regulations currently have an upper claim limit of £415,000 and a claim excess of no more than £100.

However, financial organisations are concerned about the potential impact of these changes on the sector’s landscape, with particular concern around how it could effect the smaller players in the field, and their ability to compete with the big boys. Smaller providers like Monzo, Metro Bank and Startling have some of the highest proportion of APP scams per transaction, with over a 100 frauds per million transfers – there is real concern that changes like this could rock the foundations of these relatively new financial organisations.  

‘Significant problems’

The new regulations do nod towards there being some onus on the customer to being wise to the potential for scams, stating that if a bank does not consider that a person has been sufficiently ‘careful’, there may be a consideration about whether any repayment is due. However, the PSR stresses that this threshold will only be met in very few cases, and it doesn’t apply to vulnerable customers.  

This is somewhat contrary to a controversial lawsuit in 2023 involving a major high street bank which ruled that banks can’t be held responsible for fraudulent transactions if the customers themselves had authorised the payment from their account.  

Under the new regs, consumers need to promptly notify their bank of suspected fraud, share information with their bank to help them assess a claim and consent to fraud details being reported to the police.

Simply failing to carry out one of these actions isn’t enough to not pay out though – the bank has to be able to prove that they have acted with ‘gross negligence’ – a high bar to meet.

Fintech fraud

The UK is Europe’s largest fintech hub, and the investment growth shows no sign of slowing.

The letter highlights that whilst the new regulations are undoubtably a boost for consumers, there is a very real risk that they will end up as the death knell for many smaller fintechs. The issue is not unique to the UK though and is being tackled very differently across the rest of Europe. 

There is real concern that the organisation that have made our shores their home may risk feeling unsupported, or worse, end up being unviable due to the structuring of the new regulations. With watchdogs having an obligation not only to police the sector, but also to promote growth and competitiveness within the sector, and ensure the UK is the best place to build a business, there is a question over whether this may be an own goal from the PSR.

More Financial Crime Articles

Lutine Bell
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.