‘Light touch’ regulation rejected by FCA
Posted on 13th December 2024
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has rejected calls to adopt a ‘light-touch’ regulatory approach, responding to criticism that its stringent measures may hinder economic growth.
Speaking before the Treasury Committee, FCA Chief Executive Nikhil Rathi and Chair Ashley Alder addressed the challenges of meeting the regulator’s statutory objective to enhance the UK’s global competitiveness, as reported in the Financial Times.
‘We’re at an inflection point,’ Alder said, highlighting the difficult trade-offs involved in promoting informed and responsible risk-taking by firms and customers. He noted that similar questions about the balance between regulation and growth are being raised in other major financial centres, though the issue is particularly prominent in the UK.
The government has pledged to roll back post-financial crisis regulations, arguing that they have overburdened financial firms. Last November, Chancellor Rachel Reeves sent a remit letter to the FCA, instructing it to prioritise a secondary objective introduced last year: fostering growth and competitiveness in the UK’s financial sector.
In their response, Rathi and Alder emphasised the importance of maintaining high regulatory standards while advocating for global cooperation. However, they acknowledged that achieving this balance might become increasingly challenging.
They identified green finance and crypto assets as two areas where the FCA’s approach could diverge from international norms.
‘When it comes to standards for firms, our view is that these need to remain high,’ Alder told MPs. He firmly rejected a return to the ‘light-touch’ pre-crisis regulatory environment, which he said ultimately ‘ended in tears’. He did, however, stress the need for proportionality in regulation – certainly music to the ears of many financial services professionals.
Alder pointed to significant FCA initiatives aimed at supporting growth, including reforms to capital markets and changes to listing rules introduced earlier this year. He described the effort to mobilise domestic savings, such as pensions, as a particularly challenging task.
Rathi acknowledged the inherent risks of loosening certain regulations. He said: ‘Changes to listing rules designed to make it easier for companies to float on London’s stock market mean more things will go wrong over time.
‘The real test will come when those things happen, and Parliament’s tolerance for such situations will be critical’.
The FCA’s recent call for feedback on streamlining its rulebook drew over 170 responses, reflecting mixed views from the industry.
During the session, Conservative MP and former Treasury Minister John Glen suggested the FCA could adopt a more US-style approach, where the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) swiftly approves firms but conducts rigorous reviews later. Rathi was swift to point out that the US has separate regulators for consumer protection and relies heavily on litigation. ‘It takes a long time to remove a non-compliant firm from the regulatory perimeter once they’re in,’ he warned.