Is profit a dirty word?
Posted on 11th December 2025
In the financial services sector, the word profit often carries a complicated weight. For some, it’s the ability to deliver sustainable growth. For others, it conjures images of money-hungry decision-making that risks overshadowing customer outcomes.
As regulators tighten their grip and boards wrestle with balancing shareholder expectations against consumer protection, the question arises: is profit a dirty word, or is it an essential part of responsible governance?
The regulatory lens
Regulators have a fairly hefty job on their hands. Safeguarding markets, protecting consumers and ensuring stability is no mean feat. Yet their increasing demands – from capital adequacy requirements to Consumer Duty frameworks – are reported to be directly impacting commercial viability, especially for smaller organisations, start-ups and those straddling multiple jurisdictions.
Compliance costs rise, margins shrink and innovation can be stifled. While regulators often stress proportionality, boards frequently feel the tension between meeting regulatory expectations and maintaining a viable business model.
The challenge is whether regulators fully appreciate the commercial consequences of their actions. A new reporting requirement may seem minor from a policy perspective, but for smaller firms it can mean significant investment in systems and staff. Over time, these incremental burdens can erode competitiveness, leaving customers with fewer choices and potentially higher costs. In this sense, commerciality is not about greed; it is about survival in a heavily regulated environment.
The customer perspective
Customers themselves often hold contradictory views. On one hand, they expect financial services firms to operate responsibly, prioritising consumer outcomes and fairness – with minimal mistakes and no room for error. Fair enough, FS firms are holding the country’s hard-earned money, after all.
On the other hand though, these firms are commercial entities, not charities. Banks, insurers and asset managers must generate profit to sustain operations, invest in innovation and provide long-term stability. Otherwise, it’ll be back to the shoebox under the mattress for the rainy day savings…
The clash comes when customers perceive profit motives as conflicting with their interests. Hidden fees or murky pricing tactics don’t help with building consumer confidence (and is all too often called out by Martin Lewis!). However, when firms deliver value transparently and responsibly, customers rarely object to commercial success. In fact, many equate profitability with reliability, trusting that a financially healthy institution is better positioned to serve them – and less likely to go under, taking their pension with it.
Boards and a commercial mindset
Boards sit at the intersection of these competing pressures. They must be commercially minded enough to ensure sustainability, yet sufficiently customer-focused to meet regulatory and societal expectations – not an enviable position.
The question is not whether boards should be commercial – they must be – but how they define commerciality? Is it purely about maximising shareholder returns, or is it about balancing profitability with purpose?
Increasingly, boards are recognising that commerciality and customer outcomes are not mutually exclusive. A business that consistently delivers poor outcomes will eventually lose customers, reputation and profitability. Conversely, a business that prioritises transparency, fairness and innovation can build loyalty and trust, which in turn drives sustainable commercial success. The challenge is to build this mindset into board strategy, ensuring that commercial decisions are aligned with long-term customer value.
Should leaders feel guilty about profit?
Senior leadership teams often wrestle with the morality of profit. In an age of heightened scrutiny, being seen as profit-driven can feel uncomfortable, particularly when regulators and media highlight consumer harm. But, surely profit is not inherently unethical, in fact, it is the fuel that enables organisations to invest and innovate, bringing better services to consumers, and delivering products that create solutions where they are needed.
Leaders should not feel guilty about being commercially minded. Instead, they should feel accountable for ensuring that profit is achieved responsibly. Embedding consumer outcomes into strategy, measuring success not only in financial terms but also in terms of customer satisfaction, trust and wider societal impact.
Commerciality is a reality of operating within financial services (any service, really), and when pursued responsibly, it can be a force for good. Regulators must remain mindful of how their demands impact commercial viability, customers must recognise that financial services are profit-making entities, and boards must embrace commerciality as part of their duty – not in opposition to consumer outcomes, but in alignment with them.