As of today (Monday, 7th October) the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) will require more than 1,500 banks, fintechs, and payment firms to reimburse victims of authorised push payment (APP) fraud, with a cap of £85,000 per claim.

The groundbreaking legislation, which has seen two years of controversial development to come to fruition, is delivered after much industry lobbying and government pressure.

As of now, all refunds must be shared between the sending and receiving companies, and most will need to be processed within five business days. To deny a claim, firms must prove the customer was “grossly negligent.” The new rules apply only to transfers between UK accounts and don’t cover payments made before the scheme’s starting date.

Excess

Firms can apply a £100 excess when settling fraud claims, meaning claims under £100—nearly a third of APP fraud cases last year—may not be eligible for reimbursement if firms opt to impose the excess. However, firms must notify customers about their policies and are prohibited from charging vulnerable customers.

The PSR says these measures aim to reduce financial harm while encouraging consumers to remain vigilant against scams. David Geale, PSR’s managing director, noted that payment firms are now incentivized to improve their fraud prevention systems.

Ground-breaking

The UK is the first country to mandate this type of refund regime, coinciding with other initiatives to tackle rising levels of online fraud. The Treasury recently extended the time banks have to delay or investigate suspicious payments from one to four days.

Concerns remain, however. The PSR reduced the refund cap from £415,000 to £85,000 after lobbying from fintechs and Treasury concerns. A review of high-value scams revealed only 18 instances of losses over £415,000 among more than 250,000 cases in 2023, with 411 cases exceeding £85,000.

Fintech leaders have warned that many firms are unprepared for the launch, and trade groups have voiced fears about potential losses from fraudulent claims. The Payments Association, representing over 200 members, had called for a delay and suggested a £30,000 cap to cover most cases.

Before this mandatory scheme, efforts were made to increase voluntary reimbursement rates. Major banks had signed up to a Contingent Reimbursement Model Code in 2019, overseen by the Lending Standards Board, which is being retired. Under the code, banks refunded 73% of APP fraud losses in 2023, up from 23% in 2018. TSB Bank has run its own fraud refund guarantee since 2018, reimbursing 97% of scam victims.

Concerns

Consumer groups have criticised the PSR’s decision to lower the cap, with Rocio Concha of Which? accusing the regulator of prioritizing industry concerns over victims. She argued that the lower cap reduces the motivation for banks to take fraud prevention seriously and called for the PSR to monitor protections closely.

There are also fears that criminal networks may exploit the rules to create new scams, such as posing as banks offering refunds or submitting false claims. The PSR plans to review the scheme a year after its implementation.

More Compliance Articles

Lutine Bell
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.