The Financial Conduct Authority has published key findings of a culture and non-financial misconduct survey, which examined how firms detect and handle non-financial misconduct incidents.

In February 2024, the FCA sent a survey to 1,028 regulated wholesale financial services firms asking about recorded incidents of non-financial misconduct in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

It was the first comprehensive non-financial survey across these sectors, providing the FCA a clear set of data points from which to assess behaviours within the market.   

The results revealed an increase in reported allegations from 2021 to 2023.

Interpretation

When launching the survey, the FCA noted that data might be interpreted in various ways. For example, a high number of complaints could suggest a healthy culture where employees feel empowered to speak up, while low reporting might indicate otherwise.

Over the three-year period, the most frequently reported concerns were bullying and harassment (26%) and discrimination (23%). However, 41% of cases fell under an ‘other’ category, underscoring the difficulty of categorising personal misconduct issues.

Identification

Firms identified concerns through multiple channels, including formal processes and whistleblowing, which were the most common. Some firms also used internal systems to spot potential issues. The FCA is sharing these findings to help firms benchmark their reporting and investigation processes, encouraging them to assess whether their practices for addressing non-financial misconduct are effective. Trade associations will play a significant role in coordinating industry-wide actions, and the data may be useful to stakeholders interested in workplace culture.

Sarah Pritchard, the FCA’s Executive Director of Markets and International, said: ‘We hope this data helps financial firms by giving management and boards a chance to reflect on their practices and determine if they stand out—and, if so, why.

‘The data needs context and careful analysis, but we believe transparency will help firms benchmark against their peers. Healthy workplace cultures are essential in all markets we regulate. When non-financial misconduct is unchecked, it can undermine trust, encourage a culture where wrongdoing goes unaddressed, and cause harm.’

Key findings

The survey’s executive summary highlights key findings:

  • Reports of non-financial misconduct incidents rose over the three years surveyed.
  • The types of misconduct varied across sectors, with bullying, harassment, and discrimination as the most reported types. Other types of misconduct comprised 41% of cases.
  • Firms detected issues through both formal channels like grievances (50%) and through alternative methods such as whistleblowing, as well as firm-led methods like market surveillance.
  • Disciplinary or other actions were taken in 43% of cases. Other outcomes included cases not investigated, not upheld, or investigations ongoing.
  • Incidents involving violence or intimidation were more likely to lead to disciplinary action than discrimination cases.
  • Confidentiality and settlement agreements signed by complainants declined in the wholesale banks sector, though other sectors showed no clear trend.
  • Discrimination cases most frequently resulted in settlement or confidentiality agreements.
  • Remuneration adjustments following misconduct were rare and primarily affected unvested variable pay.
  • Some firms lacked policies on whistleblowing and discipline.

The outcome

The FCA expects firms and their trade associations to use this data to evaluate their detection methods and ensure appropriate outcomes. Firms should discuss non-financial misconduct at senior management and board levels and comply with all regulatory responsibilities.

The survey findings will inform the FCA’s supervisory and policy work, and the FCA will not hesitate to take action if firms fail to meet its standards.

More Sector Intelligence Articles

Lutine Bell
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.