FCA issues stern warning to insurance industry about consumer duty failures
Posted on 22nd August 2024
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has intensified its scrutiny of the insurance sector, issuing a pointed warning to firms that are failing to meet the stringent consumer duty rules.
Despite ongoing warnings, the FCA’s latest review indicates that many insurers are still falling short in delivering fair value and good outcomes for their customers, with the regulator ‘disappointed to see many insurance firms are not fully meeting their product governance obligations’.
Too many examples
‘Insurers need to make sure their customers are getting fair value. Progress is being made, but we are still seeing too many examples of insurers and brokers lacking the right information, governance, or oversight to ensure their customers get consistently good outcomes’, said Matt Brewis, director of insurance at the FCA.
‘All insurance firms should take note of our findings and make improvements where appropriate,’ he added.
The FCA examined 28 insurance manufacturers and 39 distributors, uncovering significant deficiencies in both governance and oversight. The review revealed that many firms are not adequately assessing whether their products deliver fair value, and are failing to identify instances where customers may not be receiving the outcomes they deserve. This has raised serious questions about the industry’s commitment to consumer protection under the FCA’s consumer duty framework.
More to be done
The consumer duty rules, which took effect last July, require firms under the FCA’s jurisdiction to ensure that their practices lead to good outcomes for customers. The insurance sector in particular, has been under increasing pressure to comply with these regulations – although this latest set of results suggests there is still more work to be done.
In a notable action last September, the FCA reminded all insurance firms of their obligation to provide fair value to customers, resulting in a pause in the sale of Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) insurance earlier this year. The FCA negotiated a suspension in GAP insurance sales by 80% of firms responsible for the GAP market, due to concerns over the value these products offered.
The FCA has since allowed some GAP insurers to resume sales after making necessary adjustments, but the blanket pause of the market, combined with this most recent damning report, shows that the FCA aren’t pulling any punches in their mission to deliver entire industry compliance with the consumer duty regulations.