Fast fashion hits the LSE (slowly)
Posted on 20th May 2024
Fast fashion. Ethically more than a little dubious, environmentally an unmitigated disaster, financially… a triumph?
Singapore-headquartered fast fashion giant Shein was recently valued at $66bn in a fundraising round. Boasting 252 million app downloads, it is the world’s biggest app-based shopping platform, and showing no signs of slowing.
With a valuation like that, where else do you go than to the London Stock Exchange?
(Well, for Shein, their first stop was Wall Street – the group is now preparing to list in London, after attempting a float in New York and facing ‘regulatory hurdles and pushbacks from US lawmakers’. But that’s by the by…)
Whilst London may be the group’s second choice, they’re pushing on, in a move that’s been welcomed by both the government, and the LSE, both of whom have been campaigning hard to welcome new IPOs.
However, is Shein the sort of IPO that the LSE wants?
Regulatory crackdowns
The fashion and lifestyle e-tailor uses technical analytic data to highlight potential purchases to the buyer, all from the comfort of their phone. The prices offered are rock-bottom, due to the company’s digitalised supply chain enabling them to manage any mismatches between stock supply and demand, whilst highly automated processes within both manufacturing and processing minimise output cost.
The organisation’s global presence then allows them to deliver fashion, home, and beauty categories around the world, from a global network of suppliers.
However, this speedy processing for products across the globe has raised some serious questions about the environmental impact of Shein. According to UN Environment Programme (UNEP), the industry is the second-biggest consumer of water and is responsible for about 10% of global carbon emissions – more than all international flights and maritime shipping combined.
Shein boasts an evoluSHEIN roadmap on their website, which outlines the organisations journey towards a more sustainable future, via three strategic pillars (equitable empowerment, collective resilience and waste-less innovation) and nine associated priorities.
The priorities include decarbonisation of the supply chain, sourcing responsible materials, protection of biodiversity and animal welfare, the acceleration of sustainable innovation and empowering their talent to access their full potential.
This level of planning needs to be more than just window dressing if Shein are to continue their spread into the EU though. In March, Environment Committee MEPs adopted their recommendations for EU measures to ensure that textiles are produced in a circular, sustainable and socially just manner, something that will have a real impact on fast fashion across the globe.
MEPs say textile products sold in the EU should be more durable, easier to reuse, repair and recycle, made wherever possible of recycled fibres, and free of hazardous substances. They underline that textiles should be produced in a manner that respects human, social and labour rights, the environment and animal welfare throughout their supply chain.
The Committee called on the Commission and EU countries to adopt measures that put an end to fast fashion, starting with a clear definition of the term based on “high volumes of lower quality garments at low price levels”. Consumers should be better informed to help them make responsible and sustainable choices, including through the introduction of a “digital product passport” in the upcoming revision of the ecodesign regulation.
Admittedly, which the environmental costs are significant although seemingly being addressed, one of the biggest players on the London stage is Shell (although for how long, who knows) – not exactly an environmental heavyweight. So, whilst the public and the planet may be taking a dim view, what about the finance sector?
Will investors put their cash behind Shein?
High street heroes haven’t notoriously done well on the LSE, with fashion traditionally flopping.
Online giant ASOS joined back in early 2022, following 20 years trading shares on the junior AIM stock market. Since joining, the company has seen a steady fall.
Add in to the mix the ethical and environmental issues, and Shein is a potentially risky prospect. In addition, the organisation is based in Singapore, with the majority of its manufacturers in China. This geographical positioning leaves Shein exposed to potential geopolitical hiccups. With Chinese threats to Taiwan lingering, the risk of sanctions, frozen assets or delisting are real.
And then the potential biggest risk of all… competition. Shein held the market alone for years, dominating the app-based shopping sector. However, rivals have started to appear, and they’re not showing any sign of slowing, with the likes of Temu and TikTok Shop snapping at their heels. The general consensus is it’s now or never for a float, if Shein wants to realise the best price.