ESG Fatigue: Is ESG in Financial Services changing?
Posted on 10th March 2025
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations have rapidly become a cornerstone of corporate strategy, risk management, and financial governance.
However, in light of recent geopolitical unrest, mineral deals, changes in legislation under the Trump administration, rising ESG fatigue, and new regulations introduced across the UK and Europe, many FS organisations are reassessing the role of ESG within their businesses.
With pressures mounting from both internal and external factors, the future of ESG governance looks increasingly complex, requiring companies and financial institutions to adapt in order to maintain credibility, transparency, and compliance.
Geopolitical unrest
Recent geopolitical events have significantly impacted global markets and supply chains, prompting an undeniable ripple effect on ESG considerations.
The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has caused energy supply disruptions and has underscored the importance of managing environmental and social risks – when something starts to impact the consumer pocket, it becomes critical.
Within Europe, energy security has become a critical issue in Europe, raising questions about the sustainability of relying on fossil fuels but geopolitical risks tied to ESG factors are no longer just about environmental regulations, but have extended to security, human rights, and ethical sourcing.
Mineral deals and the changing landscape
As the global push for cleaner solutions intensifies, the role of minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and rare earth metals has come into sharper focus.
These minerals are critical for electric vehicle batteries, renewable energy systems, and other green technologies. The rush to secure these materials has led to new governance challenges for businesses, especially concerning supply chain transparency and the environmental impact of mining practices.
The UK and European markets are closely scrutinising the ethical implications of sourcing these minerals. Countries and companies that rely on mining operations in politically unstable regions or those with questionable human rights records are facing increasing pressure to demonstrate transparency and ensure responsible sourcing. In this context, ESG regulations are evolving to include specific requirements around supply chain monitoring, the traceability of raw materials, and the environmental and social impacts of extraction processes.
The sourcing of vital minerals is one of the key topics on the news today, with the Trump Vs. Zelensky Minerals Deal Debate (and its associated political spats) dominating headlines. Whilst there may be some political point scoring behind the discussions, it highlights a key issue – as technology and the modern world places more environmental impact on the planet, ESG and the guidelines surrounding it has the potential to become more of a thorn in the side of political progress.
Whilst UK financial institutions are currently under increasing pressure to not only disclose the environmental impact of their operations but also to consider broader social governance issues such as labour practices, human rights, and the ethical sourcing of minerals. The integration of ESG factors into investment decisions, including the assessment of the sustainability and ethical implications of the companies and projects they fund, particularly in the minerals sector is making ESG governance increasingly demanding – it is no surprise that colleagues in the US have seen a scraping of many regulations. The big question is whether similar changes will come into force across the pond?
The Trump impact
While the UK and Europe has made significant strides in integrating ESG into its financial governance, the role of ESG in global financial systems is also being influenced by US policy shifts.
During President Trump’s first term, the US moved away from many international ESG commitments, including withdrawing from the Paris Agreement and rolling back of certain environmental regulations. These changes had an impact on global businesses, including those operating in the UK, with significant differences in the regulatory landscapes.
The Biden administration re-embraced ESG focused policies, reintegrating climate-related risk into financial decision making. However, Trump’s reinstation back into the White House has bought into focus another term of shifting policies and ESG uncertainty, creating challenges for businesses and investors trying to anticipate long-term trends.
For UK financial governance, this toing and froing presents both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, the UK can continue to position itself as a leader in sustainable finance by upholding strict ESG regulations. On the other, UK companies with global operations are being kept on their toes trying to navigate the diverging regulatory environments. With increasing levels of regulations to consider, it is possible that the current American view of ESG being hauled out the window could make Stateside a more attractive operational option, which could be negative news for the home-grown financial markets.
ESG Fatigue
Despite the growing emphasis on ESG, there is a notable rise in ESG fatigue, particularly among businesses and investors that face mounting pressure to meet the increasing demands for transparency, reporting, and action.
For some companies, the heavy focus on ESG factors can feel overwhelming, especially when regulatory requirements are constantly evolving. Additionally, some stakeholders question whether ESG initiatives are being pursued for genuine sustainability purposes or merely for ‘greenwashing’ purposes – the practice of marketing a company’s activities as more environmentally friendly than they are.
ESG fatigue also stems from the perceived complexity of balancing financial returns with social and environmental goals. This tension is particularly evident in industries like oil and gas, where companies face intense scrutiny for their environmental impact but are still integral to global energy systems. For financial institutions, navigating this balance while adhering to ESG criteria and satisfying investors’ expectations is no easy task.
As ESG fatigue spreads, the role of ESG in UK financial governance may need to shift towards more practical, measurable frameworks that focus on tangible outcomes rather than more ‘abstract’ principles. Companies may increasingly look for ways to simplify ESG reporting and focus on real-world impact, with an emphasis on aligning their ESG goals with long-term business strategy.
Adapting to change
The global landscape is evolving in response to geopolitical unrest, ethical sourcing concerns in the minerals sector, and new regulations in the UK and Europe. Coupled with rising ESG fatigue and shifting global policies, UK businesses and financial institutions face new challenges in balancing sustainability with profitability.
To remain competitive and compliant, UK financial institutions must embrace ESG as a central pillar of their governance frameworks, ensuring it is embedded in corporate strategy and the organisation is adapting to new regulations.
As businesses navigate these complex dynamics, it is likely that the future of ESG in financial governance will hinge on striking the right balance between regulatory compliance, ethical responsibility, and the practical realities of modern business – but as the political pendulum continues to swing wildly, and the world’s economies and businesses frantically try to keep up, it would be a brave soul to pace a bet on where the environmental chips will land.