Election 2024: What does the Labour Party manifesto mean for financial services?
Posted on 17th June 2024
‘We don’t have a magic wand… but what this manifesto represents is a credible, long-term plan.’
Well, that’s according to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer, anyway.
With Labour storming ahead in the pre-election polls, it’s looking likely that the details laid out in this manifesto could well be the facts come July 4th.
Clearly the plans are popular with the public, but what would a potential Labour government mean for the financial services world?
Financial Services: Britain’s greatest success
Although it is unlikely that any of the leadership debates will sing the praises of the financial sector (not a huge crowd pleaser…) Labour has been largely positive about the industry in their manifesto.
The sector has been noted as one of ‘Britain’s greatest success stories’, and Labour pledges to create the conditions to support innovation and growth in the sector, through offering support via new technology – including Open Banking and Open Finance – and ensuring a pro-innovation regulatory framework.
All sounding largely positive, but will other policies contradict this crowd-pleasing opening line,,, or is the overall picture still looking rosy?
Kickstarting economic growth
As the election machine has rolled on, there has been plenty of talk around shaking up the financial landscape, with tax hikes and cuts being prime PR fodder.
Labour’s manifesto sets out how they plan to jiggle current rules to ‘secure the highest sustained growth in the G7, with good jobs and productivity growth in every part of the country making everyone, not just a few, better off’.
The party has made no secret of their plans to abolish non-dom status and scrap the use of offshore trusts to avoid inheritance tax, in a move that the manifesto states could add as much as £5,230 million a year to the country’s coffers. This cash has been allocated to funding 40,000 more NHS appointments a week, doubling the number of NHS CT and MRI scanners, a dentistry package, free breakfast clubs in every primary school and Investment in HMRC to reduce tax avoidance.
However, a recent article in the Telegraph questioned this figure, with data from accountancy firm Blick Rothenberg noting that the crackdown on non-doms would realistically only bring in around £8k a person – and could well end up costing more that it raises if it succeeds in driving wealthy individuals away from the UK, throwing the costing all of the above policies into question.
Labour also plans to overhaul HMRC, strengthening its powers and adding in more layers of regulation and reporting. There are plans for a recruitment drive and some powerful new technology to help cope with the new requirements, but it’s hoped that this additional red tape will close the gap on tax avoidance.
Securonomics
No, not a new class at the gym. This is Labour’s new approach to economic management. A (fairly justifiable) theory that sustainable growth relies on a broad base and resilient foundations.
Labour stresses that they plan to ‘stop the chaos and support business through a stable policy environment’, noting that the ‘country remains too centralised, with the economic potential of too many regions and communities ignored’.
The party’s approach is built on maintaining a ‘dynamic and strategic state’, and the manifesto promises a government that plans to work in active partnership with business, trade unions, local leaders and devolved governments. In a move to transfer power from Westminster, Labour is pledging to introduce landmark devolution legislation, encouraging the Combined Authorities to take control of their own regional growth. From a financial service’s perspective, this can only be a positive thing – especially for regional organisations. A central government with a closer understanding of regional requirements and quirks should hopefully offer a sympathetic and flexible approach.
Driving growth via industry is a primary focus, with plans to put in place an Industrial Strategy Council, to provide expert advice to all nations, regions and traded unions. It is noted that as a country the UK is well placed to support innovation in research institutions, professional services, advanced manufacturing, and creative industries, and the manifesto is clear that these industries will be well supported.
The National Wealth Fund
The National Wealth Fund would use public investment, capitalised with £7.3 million over the course of the next government, to support growth and clean energy pledges. Driving investment in the UK’s infrastructure and future, the idea behind the fund is to use public money to de-risk private investment.
Proposed spending would include:
- £1.8 billion to upgrade ports and build supply chains across the UK
- £1.5 billion to new gigafactories so the UK’s automotive industry leads the world
- £2.5 billion to rebuild the steel industry
- £1 billion to accelerate the deployment of carbon capture
- £500 million to support the manufacturing of green hydrogen.
The fund would require £3 of private investment for every £1 of public money, with a hope that investors will take the opportunity to place their bets on UK PLC.
Corporate competitiveness
There has been much debate about which taxes Labour are planning to hike in order to pay for their ambitious manifesto plans (the lively discussion between Angela Rayner and Penny Mordaunt was something to behold).
Rayner was clear that VAT and income tax would not be increased, but what of business taxes? For investors or start-ups, this can be a make or break when it comes to choosing a geographical base.
The manifesto promises to cap corporation tax at the current level of 25%, which puts us at the lowest rate in the G7 for the duration of the parliament, and pledges to act if tax changes in other countries pose a risk to UK competitiveness.
One of the most important elements for the financial sector is that the document commits to only one major fiscal event a year, giving everyone a fair warning of policy changes. There is also the promise of the publication of a roadmap, allowing reliable horizon planning, safe in the knowledge that nothing will creep up unexpectedly. Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves also announced that the party plan to use their first King’s Speech (if successful!) to introduce legislation giving the Office for Budget Responsibility greater powers which would allowing the OBR to independently publish a forecast of any major fiscal events that could impact tax or spending changes. The theory being that an independent OBR forecast would offer adequate forewarning of any upcoming highs or lows, preventing a meltdown like we saw after Liz Truss’s chaotic mini-budget.
Welcoming AI… within reason
AI has swept through the financial services sector, with no sign of slowing. London has recently been named as the number one investment location in Europe for FinTech, and the FCA has been overwhelmingly more flexible that it’s European counterparts on regulation around AI – all in all, the UK is a sympathetic location for AI embedding, both for start-ups and established organisations.
Labour’s industrial strategy supports the development of the Artificial Intelligence (AI) sector, removing planning barriers to new datacentres. Short funding cycles for key R&D institutions are also set to be scrapped, in favour of ten-year budgets that allow meaningful partnerships with industry to keep the UK at the forefront of global innovation.
It’s not all about speed and ease though, there is also attention paid to the safety element required to manage such a powerful force. To ensure the safe development and use of AI models, a binding regulation will be introduced for the most powerful AI models, and the creation of sexually explicit deepfakes will be banned.
Regulation, regulated
Innovation is clearly important, and vital to the growth of the country, but as with AI, it is clear that new technologies and developments may foster the need for additional regulation.
Financial service firms are no stranger to regulation, and unlike other parties, Labour are not shying away from the potential of introducing more.
The manifesto notes that currently, regulators are ill-equipped to deal with the dramatic development of new technologies. Clearly, supporting these are in the plan, so Labour has pledged to create a new Regulatory Innovation Office, to help regulators update regulation, speed up approval timelines, and co-ordinate issues that span existing boundaries.
Ultimately, someone to regulate the regulators. For compliance and audit teams, this new body may be a blessing or a curse – only time will tell – but better co-ordination of issues and clarity must be a positive.
Banking Hubs
The Labour Party has promised to open 350 banking hubs if it comes to power, pledging to ‘bring banking back to the high street.’
Hubs would work in the same way as individual bank branches currently do, giving people face-to-face access to their banking requirements, however instead of being one branch per bank, a hub would be utilised by a number of different banks simultaneously. There are 56 banking hubs currently in existence in the UK.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) would be given the task of setting the criteria for where hubs should be created, under new powers provided by the government, and they’ll have to be fairly openminded about the areas they choose – Labour has promised to ‘quickly establish at least 350’ hubs over the next five years.
In order to do so, they would have to rip up the existing rule book on qualifying criteria, something they are keen to do, it seems, having stated that the current criteria has ‘unfairly denied’ some communities the banking services they seek. Areas with no current banking provisions will rise to the top of the queue.
Making work pay
Wherever you are on your career ladder, employment legislation is a key consideration. Whether worrying about your child leaving university and taking their first steps into the world of work, or navigating change in your own more established career path, we are all impacted by employment law.
Labour’s ‘Plan to Make Work Pay: Delivering a New Deal for Working People’, which they hope to implement within 100 days if they are successful on July 4th, has been designed to strengthen the voice of workers. The changes would include banning zero hours contracts; ending fire and rehire; and introducing basic rights from day one to parental leave, sick pay, and protection from unfair dismissal; and the creation of a Single Enforcement Body to ensure employment rights are upheld.
There are also plans to make amendments to the Equality Act 2010, with a strong focus on women’s equality, racial discrimination and the rights of people with disabilities.
The Make Work Pay plan promises to transform the working lives of women, by strengthening rights to equal pay and protections from maternity and menopause discrimination and sexual harassment. And Labour will take action to reduce the gender pay gap, building on the legacy of Barbara Castle’s Equal Pay Act.
A landmark Race Equality Act, to enshrine in law the full right to equal pay for Black, Asian, and other ethnic minority people, will also be introduced, in a bid to build on protections against dual discrimination and racial inequalities.
The rights of people living with disabilities are also being re-examined, with a promise to introduce the full right to equal pay for disabled people, built on the same premise as gender pay gap reporting. Disability support at work will also be prioritised, with a focus in improving employment support and access to reasonable adjustments.
‘Green finance capital of the world’
The manifesto outlines Labour’s high hopes that the UK will become the ‘green finance capital of the world,’ mandating UK-regulated financial institutions – including banks, asset managers, pension funds, and insurers – and FTSE 100 companies to develop and implement credible transition plans that align with the 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement. The Bank of England will also be required to give due consideration to climate change in its mandates.
However, this isn’t just a regulatory box to tick… a concise CSR investment programme can be a highly attractive proposal, and Labour has outlined an impressive one within their manifesto.
If we see a Labour government at Westminster, we will also be seeing the launch of publicly owned company, Great British Energy (GBE), set to deliver clean, home-grown energy. Headquartered in Scotland and partnering with industry and trade unions, GBE will help support capital-intensive projects and co-invest in leading technologies, providing clead energy across the UK through a combination of onshore wind, solar, and hydropower projects.
Labour will capitalise Great British Energy with £8.3 billion over the next parliament, but how will they pay for it? Closing the loopholes on windfall tax for oil and gas for a start, raising an expected £1.2 billion. In doing so, they also extend the sunset clause in the Energy Profits Levy until the end of the next parliament.
However, the financial services industry is being called on to play its part here too, with the manifesto noting that it ‘has a major role to play in mobilising trillions of pounds in private capital to address the greatest long-term challenge of our age’.
Facing fraud head on
Given Keir Starmer’s previous role, it is hardly surprising that the Labour manifesto has a heavy focus on the UK’s justice system.
With regards to the financial services space, fraud plays a significant role in the plan, with the document outlining how this crime now accounts for 40% of crime in the UK. It documents how the current government have failed to respond to the ‘scale of the challenge’ and promises to introduce a new strategy to tackle the full spectrum of threats, including online, public sector and serious fraud. Financial service professionals will be pleased to hear that the party has also outlined how they plan to work closely with technology companies to stop their platforms being exploited by fraudsters, in a move that will undoubtably we welcomed by financial crime professionals.
Foreign affairs
Contrary to Westminster whispers, under Labour government, Britain would be staying firmly outside of the EU. However, the party has pledged to make Brexit work and promises to ‘reset the relationship and seek to deepen ties with our European friends, neighbours and allies’.
With growing the economy the continual theme of the manifesto, the foreign policy promises are no different. The diplomatic network would be utilised to attract foreign direct investment into the UK, expand markets for British exporters, and shape emerging regulatory frameworks.
Plans include seeking targeted trade agreements aligned with the overall industrial strategy and economic strengths; leading international discussions to modernise trade rules and agreements so they work for Britain; promoting deeper trade and co-operation including through the World Trade Organisation and the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership.
A special mention is made to recognising the growing political and economic importance of African countries, with a nod towards delivering a new approach to the continent to foster opportunities for mutual long-term benefit.
Bringing transport back on track
There is a heavy focus on the state of the UK’s transport infrastructure, a cause close to many hearts with organisations moving back to an in-office structure, making a commute a daily chore again.
After the chaos of HS2 and the mismanagement of many regional contracts, Labour has shone a particular spotlight on Britain’s railways. Labour hopes to get things back on track by re-nationalising the railways, bringing them into public ownership and taking responsibility for investment, day-to-day operational delivery, innovations and improvements for passengers.
Regionally, Mayors will play a part in designing services in their areas, and a new watchdogs will be formed, with a responsibility for driving up standards for passengers. From a commuter’s point of view, largely positive (although they are unlikely to be able to do much about leaves on the line)!
The school fees saga
We couldn’t overview the Labour manifesto without touching on one of the more controversial policies, the tax hike on private schools.
Whilst certainly not something that will impact everyone, it will certainly be a heavy blow to those it does touch, and it has certainly something that has received a huge mount of airtime. So, what does the actual manifesto promise say?
Much has been noted about raising school standards for every child and making sure they are best supported and well prepared for the future. Certainly, something everyone would agree on, regardless of where you stand on the state vs public school debate. But for parents of children at public school, the proposed ending of end the VAT exemption and business rates relief for private schools to invest further in state schools is a bitter pill.
According to a report by the IFS, in 2022–23, average private school fees across the UK were £15,200 (net of bursaries and scholarships), nearly 90% higher than the £8,000 per head spent at state school. This gap has more than doubled since 2010, when the gap averaged at 40%.
So, will there be a sudden flood of private school pupils to state schools, overwhelming the already stretched system? It seems unlikely. The number of pupils across the UK in private schools has remained around 6–7% for at least the last 20 years, despite a 20% real-terms increase in average private school fees since 2010 and a 55% rise since 2003. For parents with children already in the private education system, it is likely that children will remain where they are, however data over the next seven years (the length of a secondary school career from year 7 at aged 11 to the end of A-levels at 18) may show a decline, as more parents choose the more economical option. However things pan out in the long term, the change promises to bring in a hefty chunk of change, with VAT and business rate application to private schools set to raise an additional £1,510m. Bad news for fee paying parents, but potentially positive for pupils.
So, the Labour manifesto.
No-drama Starmer, or could this cause the financial sector absolute chaos?