Calming the clash: Managing workplace conflict
Posted on 2nd May 2024
‘The aim of argument, or of discussion, should not be victory, but progress’.
This quote, by French writer Joseph Joubert, is as true now as it was when he noted it in 1848.
In an ideal world, we would obviously have no need for conflict in the workplace at all. After all, wouldn’t it just be nicer if everyone just got along? Wishful thinking perhaps, when you put a lot of people together in a potentially stressful environment, there is bound to be times when hackles are raised – it’s human nature.
So, if conflict arises, how do you take a leaf out of Joubert’s book and move the situation forward – not just calming troubled waters, but coming to a satisfactory solution that keeps everyone happy?
Why is conflict management important?
Financial services is a stressful industry. It should not be underestimated how much pressure is on the shoulders of the teams who manage the flow of capital through the UK’s economy.
It is no surprise that with so much at stake, tensions can sometimes run high.
According to a 2021 report produced by Professor Richard Saundry of the University of Sheffield Management School and Professor Peter Urwin of the Centre for Employment Research, University of Westminster for Acas, this is an issue that needs to be addressed, for both the good of employees, and the bottom line.
The report revealed that the equivalent of ten million UK employees suffered conflict at work, with over half reporting to suffer stress, anxiety or depression as a result. Off the back of these issues, it’s believed that just under 900,000 people were taking time off work due to fall outs on company time, half a million people handed in their resignation and more than 300,000 people were let go.
Clearly, this will have an impact on business efficiencies, and the report suggested that workplace conflicts came at a cost of £28.5 billion a year, which equates to just over £1,000 for each employee.
Conflict management techniques
Clearly managing conflict within a team is a skill, and not one that should be underestimated. Whilst a little bit of spark can sometimes be a good thing, driving innovation and creating new opportunities, too much can cause tension and an unpleasant atmosphere, and nobody thrives within that environment.
With so much at stake, what can you do if you feel the steam rising within your team?
According to the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Modelling Tool, developed by psychologists Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann in the 1970s, there are five simple techniques you can employ to remove tension from the workplace,
Which technique you use depends on the situation, and the assertiveness and cooperation of the individuals involved, however it offers good guidance for different resolution styles that can be applied to most situations.
The five techniques are:
Accommodating
This style is all about considering the desires of the other person and putting them above your own.
If the relationship with the other person is important, the accommodating style can allow for you to yield to their needs, forgoing your own concerns.
Ranking high on the cooperation score, but low on assertiveness, it will undoubtably help safeguard a working relationship, there is the potential for this style to build resentment long term, and of course a risk of issues being left unchallenged. However, if a conflict has minimal impact, and is threatening to damage an otherwise positive relationship, this can provide a fast and effective resolution.
Avoiding
Burying your head in the sand about an issue may not seem like a particularly effective method for conflict management… but according to the experts, it’s a valid option in some situations.
An undeniably passive approach, avoidance results in neither party addressing the issue, instead letting it fade away and be forgotten. The risk here is that old resentments are rarely every truly forgotten, and always have the potential to resurface – adding fuel to the fire further down the line.
If a conflict arises within a short-term relationship – possibly with a consultant, for example, or within a team facing a project deadline – this method could be an option. Or, if you need some bandwidth to properly consider the outcomes of managing the conflict (could it result in a department reshuffle, for example), avoidance can give you the space needed to work within a less tense environment. However, for a long-term solution, it should be approached with caution.
Compromising
In an ideal world, you would hope to be able to meet the needs of all of your team members… but in lieu of a magic wand, there may need to be an element of compromise from everyone.
The compromising method of conflict resolution calls on all parties to bend a little in order to find a middle ground that works for everyone – on paper, an ideal option, but in reality this can be easier said than done!
With this method, it is likely that the level of compromise is uneven, with some parties less satisfied with the outcome than others. This is particularly true of you are moderating a conflict including team members who may be different levels of seniority – it is natural that the more junior may feel less able to confidently vocalise their requests.
Collaborating
Thought of to be the most effective long-term approach, collaboration can also be the most complicated and lengthy to execute – however it is likely to put the issue to bed, once and for all, so probably time well spent.
This approach requires everyone involved to come to the table with an open mind, and a willingness to come together to find a solution. This isn’t always easy, as it may involve people accepting fault and potentially negotiating solutions that they may not be happy with, but this process is about defining the end result, not debating the initial issue.
As with compromising, this methos can be tricky if you are working with team members of varying seniority, however if everyone is open and willing to drive change, it can be a highly effective conflict management style.
Competing
As a manager, you are often in an unenviable position of having to make decisions that don’t go down well with everyone. When it comes to resolving conflict in the workplace, unfortunately you have a hefty chance of annoying someone with the outcome, whatever you choose.
The competing method embraces this, shunning compromise and tackling fall outs with dominance, a ‘my way or the highway’ style of conflict management.
Some situations mean that no decision you make is going to be well received. If you find yourself in a situation where you need to make a quick (potentially unpopular) decision, this method is effective – akin to ripping off a plaster. It’ll definitely get the job done quickly, but it might not be comfortable and it may leave a scar.
Lowering morale and leaving a bad taste in the mouth of your team is never the aim, but if a dispute threatens to derail a team, sometimes a resolution needs to be reached quickly and effectively, for the good of the wider organisation.
Management skills
Knowing the techniques is one thing, putting them into practice is quite another.
Managing a conflict between team members can be a daunting task, and feeling unprepared can make it feel like you’re stepping into a lion’s den.
However, failing to manage a tense situation is just allowing issues to multiply. The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development note that 40% of employees who had experienced conflict in the workplace noted that they had had a drop in motivation, with 36% feeling less committed to their role.
Clearly, these are not thing you want in your team, not do you want anyone you are responsible for managing to feel stressed or anxious at the thought of coming to work.
So, as a manager, what do you need to be on top of to make sure that you are well placed to sort out any issues that arise?
- Stay alert: keep our eyes and ears open for any bubbling issues. Conflict doesn’t have to be explosive, sometimes the smallest niggles, if left unchecked, can develop into real issues
- Listen, and then listen some more: Let your team speak openly to you about the issues, don’t try and solve anything before you have the full picture, from everyone involved.
- Learn from the issues: Once you have found a resolution, consider what steps can be put in place to ensure the same thing doesn’t happen again.
- Remain neutral, and calm: Conflict creates stress, you should be a point of calm during this troubled time.
- Process clarity: You should ensure that all of your team members are clear on the procedures for raising a complaint, and confident that if they need to do so, it will be managed promptly and taken seriously.
Above all, stay positive. Being the sounding board for other people’s issues can be a thankless task…but so is managing a failing team. Don’t allow yourself to get embroiled in the negativity of the situation, remember that you are looking for a resolution, not wanting to become part of the conflict.