Here in Britain, we are known for a few things. Tea, queuing, and overwhelming politeness even in the most uncomfortable situations. But is our desire to reduce tension having an impact on our productivity?

In too many boardrooms, politeness has replaced challenge. Nods of tentative agreement are the norm, but may mean that the harder questions go unasked. But according to some of the country’s most senior leaders, productive tension is not something to fear, it is the lifeblood of good governance, helping organisations move from surface-level consensus to the actual heart of the issue.

Why tension matters

Boards are inherently vulnerable to the comfort of groupthink. Without diverse perspectives and constructive dissent, blind spots remain hidden until they evolve into risks. Tension, when well-managed, becomes a strategic asset. It can sharpen vague ambition into actionable strategy, transforming debate into a source of strength, whilst building resilience. Boards that challenge well, adapt well.

When pressure mounts – whether that be from markets, regulators, or an unexpected hiccup – it’s the teams accustomed to asking the uncomfortable questions that are more likely to spring into action.

Challenging without being… challenging

Of course, there is a fine line between being able to challenge, and being abrasive. Continually pushing back for the sake of it is not going to win you many friends, or influence people in a particularly helpful way. Instead, you may find yourself less effective than you were to start with!

It is true to assume that most people will tale their seat at the Boardroom table – whether as a Board Member or an invited associate – feeling well prepared and confident in their presentations. For anyone to them question their plans, statements or thoughts, can feel abrasive. That said, it is important to speak up if it is needed, there’s a chance you won’t be the only one with the same thoughts.  

Jason Edwards, CCO at Saltus, shared one of the unusual tricks that he and his Board-level colleagues implement if they need to be frank, and potentially confrontational, across the Boardroom table:

‘We decided we needed a safe word! Somebody suggested baba ghanoush – like the dip – and it stuck, after all, it’s unlikely to come up in a board meeting otherwise!

‘Now, if you are in a meeting, and you start a conversation with the phrase ‘baba ghanoush’, then the person you are addressing knows immediately that what is about to be said is purely and utterly business, and it’s nothing personal.

‘We all just understand that when someone says ‘baba ghanoush’, we need to be gloves off, because this comment matters. I’ve got to tell you how it is, because otherwise, this could be an issue – but remember it’s not personal. It’s made a real difference to how open our board meetings are, and how open we are as a senior leadership team’.

Tone, too, plays a critical role in making sure any disagreements raised are helpful, rather than harmful. Ensuring you keep any criticism firmly focused on the data, risk or potential outcomes, rather than any behaviours or individual deliveries, helps keeps potential disagreements constructive, and prevents it from becoming personal. After all, a debate is there to move things on, not drive a wedge between colleagues!

International INED, Board Chair, Audit, Risk, Nomco & Remco Committee Chair, Cameron Marr noted the importance of trying to maintain good Board relationships, and the importance of pulling together, even when things get tough:  

‘A big challenge is balancing oversight with support, especially when things are not going well.

‘This will undoubtedly create a sense of tension, which is when adrenaline rises and emotions flare, and this can become confrontational. Your sense of perspective can be narrowed, and support can become interventionary or directional.  But this is when the sense of collective within the Board becomes very important’.

When applied correctly, tension doesn’t have to be chaotic. It can provide the perfect amount of force to drive change, preventing a slack and messy alternative.  

More Sector Intelligence Articles

Lutine Bell
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.