As General Counsel at Just Group PLC Fiona Lavender-Brown is a force to be reckoned with in the insurance and pensions world.

However, despite her history at industry heavyweights such as Lloyds TSB, RBS, Direct Line and Saga, Fiona still isn’t convinced she fits the mould of a typical lawyer…

The training that we get as lawyers is naturally very structured, attracting individuals who are generally not as creative by nature… the industry attracts a certain type of person and if I am honest, I have always been the fish that swims in the opposite direction. ‘

‘I have always felt that I’m not really a lawyer. I love the law and have been imbibed in it my whole career, it’s what I always wanted to do, but I know I’m not the norm. The greatest compliment that people used to give me was that ‘you just don’t act like a lawyer’!

We caught up with Fiona to discuss why she’s spent a career swimming against the shoal, her thoughts on how the sector is championing diversity and the importance of saying ‘no’.

Oh, and not forgetting which Winnie the Pooh character she most resonates with… (hint, it’s a very bouncy one)!

What skills have helped you succeed?

‘First and foremost, an ability to get on with people. In business, we deal with so many different types of people, so the ability to get on with people must be number one, closely followed by commercial acumen. I would also say being energised by change and not being frightened by it, has been a constant throughout my career.

‘I don’t believe it is the technical skills that differentiate you in your career, rather it’s your own desire to build your career – your own drive. I also do think a lot of it is luck. I know that has come up in other people’s career journeys, but as it is a very competitive market, if you actively desire to drive your own career and you’re willing to be flexible, agile and embrace change, in my experience you’ll always thrive – in-house especially.

‘You’ve got to be able to think on your feet. You’re faced with quite a variety of issues in-house, you don’t have time to mull over the answer, you have to just get on with it – everyone expects you to know everything about everything! You need to have the confidence to tell people when you know something, and when you don’t, and why. The analogy I always use is that of the GP and the consultant… you wouldn’t expect your GP to know every single in-depth detail of every single medical condition, you’d go to a consultant for that, but you would hope they would have a solid overview of the general conditions you might present with.  Consider an in-house lawyer as a GP – we know something about everything, but also know when it’s necessary to call in the specialists, and absolutely won’t hesitate to do so for the health of the organisation!

‘I think what businesses are looking for – and this has been a constant for me – is people who are interested and curious in the business that you’re operating in, people who are able to apply legal knowledge to the real-life environment and evolve with it. Businesses want confident leaders who can give them solutions. They don’t want people to just preach the law to them, they want the law applied to their specific issue and lawyers who will talk to them in their language and provide solutions’.

LB: Is an in-house role right for everyone?

‘No. You get lots of different types of lawyers, with different personalities. I think some lawyers could become quite frustrated by not being able to give the clients chapter and verse on the law or are fearful of bearing the ultimate responsibility.

‘There’s a lot of judgement and decision-making when you’re working in-house, as opposed to private practice, where work is more carefully scrutinised. In-house, you are accountable for your own actions, you don’t have the safety net of a second view and some people may be fearful of that.

‘Some lawyers struggle to make that required recommendation, whilst others want to make sure everybody listens to them and does it their way. In my experience, neither style works well in-house because the client has a choice whether they take your advice or not. Personally, my preference is to gain my client’s trust to such an extent that when I say no, it is so rare that they think ‘oh my goodness, she’s serious’, because I will always try to find pragmatic solutions if I can, so a no is rare! But if I can’t find that solution, or the legal risk is just too great and I feel what they are asking is a step too far, it is important that I am confident in telling them so’.

What advice would you give to someone looking to move into your sector?

‘There are quite a few sectors that are steeped in regulation and financial services is rightly one of them. You absolutely must be prepared to be confident and steadfast about what you don’t know, as much as what you do.

‘I have only dabbled outside of the financial services sector once during my career, when I was at Saga. Saga was predominantly a financial services business yet had an outstanding reputation for its travel and cruise businesses. At my interview, I was asked by the Group CFO ‘so what do you know about shipping?’ My response was ‘I know nothing, which is why I’d get a specialist law firm to advise’. You can’t know everything, but that confidence comes with maturity – some lawyers believe they must know everything, and that is simply not true. It would never be advisable to bluff about shipping!

‘I recruited one of my senior lawyers from a completely different sector. She’d been in the fuel distribution sector, yet I felt she had the right credentials to come to work for me, but I could see that she was concerned about the change to a completely different sector – unknown territory. During our interview I told her, ‘I just want you to be brave, and take a leap of faith’. It’s a high learning curve but lawyers’ skills are generally interchangeable, regardless of the sector, and once you’ve mastered the jargon, understand the market, the company and what I call my three Ps – people, products and processes – you can flex your legal knowledge and skills accordingly.

‘It is of far more importance to be brave and try.  I am delighted to say, my colleague took that leap of faith to become one of the highest performing lawyers in our team.  I am so proud of her for believing in herself.

‘In contrast, years ago, I invited a senior lawyer in wealth management into my insurance team within the same banking group. She was unable to adapt, despite the minor shift moving from one part of financial services to another. She was an excellent lawyer, and I was saddened that it was her own limiting belief that prevented her from embracing the change. If you are prepared to open yourself up, be fearful and vulnerable, you will be richly rewarded.

‘That said, few actively choose insurance… insurance chooses you! I don’t know anyone studying the law who shared their dream saying: ‘I’m going to go and get a job in insurance!’ – but I would always encourage anyone to just take that leap of faith’!

Changes to the industry

‘My first role was with a life and pensions company, Friends Provident, now part of Aviva, and the offer came after quite a prolonged interview process. One of the tasks involved the Executive team observing the candidates working together to build a ship. We were from a variety of universities, but one candidate from  Oxford University was trying to solve the problem by taking charge and instructing us all in what to do – I was sure he would be selected as the chosen candidate and be offered the role, so I assisted with the brief, ensuring we all were included in the solution and were given an opportunity to contribute. Imagine my surprise when the offer letter landed through my door!

‘That first job offer gave me a real confidence boost at the very start of my career, because I realised that in spite of not having the best education on paper, the most educated person in the room was not successful on that occasion in getting the job.

‘You must accept that different companies are looking for different types of people and there will be many firms and companies that wouldn’t see me as a match, and I accept that – but plenty will. In following your career path, it is so important to be your most authentic self – otherwise, you will spend your career living a lie – and work is such a big part of your life, I just couldn’t do that.’

‘Companies are getting much better at being honest about hiring and encouraging people to bring their whole self to work.  I am very fortunate to be ending my career at Just Group, as it is a company that really embraces individuality and belonging – it is such a huge part of the company ethos, so different from companies I joined at the start of my career.

‘Whilst most organisations are now recruiting more women into senior positions, the process has become more integrated in recent years. There was a period where companies, particularly public companies, seemed to be filling quotas.  Whilst this was never the way to promote positive change, I suppose it did force the pace of change. I much prefer the more subtle recruitment processes these days, where CVs are presented anonymously. This is far preferable than dictating a sex to fill a quota. I suspect few would wish to be recruited on that basis – I would hate to be offered a role simply because of my gender.

‘Fortunately, in recent years we have now moved away from such strategic recruitment – to having reliable processes, that are inclusive and fair. I accept that it takes a long time to change mindsets, but at Just, we educate our colleagues on diversity through story telling. Story telling is much more impactful at educating people’s mindsets. I am not convinced that people change how they think just because you tell them to, they’ll just resent being told to think a certain way, which can be counterproductive. Hiring an effective high performing team is about hiring people with different expertise, experience, backgrounds and personalities – which in itself delivers diversity. You don’t want a mirror image of yourself, you want a team of balanced lawyers who create the magic of synergy, preferably where individuals are much better than you!’

What challenges do you face most often?

‘In my experience very few people’s career is plain sailing. You need to have a few hiccups along the way, and in my experience, such challenges have brought with them monumental and positive change.

‘I’ve been incredibly lucky to have been employed by companies who are experiencing their toughest times. Not only is it incredibly interesting but provides you with your greatest personal growth and learning. I joined a small life and pensions company, soon after regulation had been introduced to the financial services sector. The Executive team didn’t appreciate the shackles of regulation and decided to fly in the face of it.  Unsurprisingly, the company was closed down, but the process was so valuable for both me and the reputable accountancy firm, who was able to peddle their experience from the torrid episode many times over. A valuable lesson for everyone!

‘Having just given birth to my eldest son, I was made redundant in a way that wouldn’t even be contemplated today.  I was offered another role within weeks, but the subject of my 4-month-old son had not been mentioned at the interview and was only discussed at a social event some weeks later.  I recall my boss’s horror at the revelation, thereafter, sending me on field trips all over the country.  I remember on one occasion, immediately before the Easter break, being sent to two separate counties hundreds of miles away – I had to start at 4am and I got home after midnight – fortunately, such behaviours wouldn’t be tolerated today. There were days when I just wanted to walk out of the building, as the subtle negative behaviours and unreasonable demands continued but that little bit of steel in me wouldn’t let the experience get the better of me. Fortunately, a new CEO arrived and within weeks, I was promoted to Head of Legal.

‘Another challenge comes to mind in a much larger company where, following a restructure, my role was diluted so I decided that I had no choice but to leave.  Whilst I certainly had to feel the fear, with no imminent job prospect on the horizon, I never regretted my decision. If a role is no longer satisfying you, you are letting yourself down to stay’.

What keeps you motivated day-to-day?

‘People – 100% people.

‘My role is to lead the team and solve the business problems. I’m here to really help the business to be the best that it can be, but I cannot do that without the right people.

‘I have always said I don’t see my team as just a team, I see them as collective of individuals who can be nurtured to fulfil their own aspirations, which for me is much bigger motivation than the actual job.

‘I feel blessed to have spent the majority of my career, with a variety of different colleagues, not just lawyers. Learning from marketing gurus, accountants, actuaries, project managers and many others who think very differently to you. I get a lot from that diversity of talent.

‘I have had the privilege of being mentored by some great people along the way. That first interview, building the ship, little did I know that my future boss would become such an important mentor and role model for me for the rest of my career. Creating cheerleaders around you is a very good way to shape your career.

‘I have the most junior person in my team mentoring me now, I love it! Although a generation apart and at such different stages of our careers, we see life so differently, yet also have so much commonality. I would recommend to anyone to try it. Our recent AI rollout is another a good example. I deliberately selected our junior team members to do the initial research, only bringing in the more experienced lawyers to fill some of the gaps gained by experience.

‘For me, another major factor for career success is to be passionate about your business. There are certain companies that would either not excite me or would not match my personal values.  In the early stages of one of my roles, I realised within the first week that my personal values and the corporate values were not aligned.  I refer back to Just Group, which is experiencing unprecedented growth and ambition, which is an intangible benefit seldom experienced in my career’.

If you could do any other job in the world, what would you do?

‘When I was younger, I always wanted to be Tigger at Disney World, in the full costume, but I have matured since then.

‘I think I would do something more on the caring side, because I am naturally more of a nurturer. I was taught to be very independent and self-sufficient from a very young age and my drive came from a lack of expectation for me.

‘My career was definitely influenced by my childhood and upbringing. My mother had no expectations of me, I had nothing to prove, no one was putting a lot of pressure on me apart from myself. Had I not had that, I suspect my career would have been very different.

What’s your key takeaway?

You are in charge of your own destiny – make it a reality – I get quite frustrated with people who do not take personal responsibility for their own career progression.

‘It’s down to you at the end of the day. Take responsibility for your own destiny’.

More A Day in the Life Of... Articles

Lutine Bell
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.