A Day in the Life Of: Cultural alignment advocate and M&A CCO, Jason Edwards
Posted on 9th May 2024
Baba ghanoush may not be something you hear mentioned often in board meetings, unless you’re Jason Edwards, CCO at Saltus, or one of his board-level colleagues.
This dip-inspired turn-of-phrase has revolutionised the way the Saltus board work to great effect.
‘Compliance people by their nature tend to take time to get to a decision’, he told Lutine Bell.. ‘Even then the decision might or might not be possible’.
‘However, when you’re working at board level you can’t do that, and the pace is something that you have to adjust to, so you need baba ghanoush to keep things moving’!
Grab a pitta, and let’s get the scoop on how…
What skills have helped you succeed?
‘There’s a difference between skills and knowledge. You can be very knowledgeable, know every chapter in the handbook and every consultation paper the FCA has ever come out with, but that won’t make you good at the job. In the same way, you can be brilliant with people, very charming and articulate, but if you don’t understand what you’re talking about, you won’t be very good at the job…
‘When we talk about skills, the things I have always held as valuable is the ability to manage multiple people. Sometimes you are having a conversation with an advisor, sometimes somebody from due diligence, sometimes a really senior director or a non-exec director. You have to be able to adjust your style and approach so that it lands well with the correct person. If you just go in and say “compliance says no”, that will just reinforce the stereotype that we’re just the red tape brigade and purely there to put blockers on doing the exciting stuff.
Our job is not just to protect the backs of people that work in boardrooms so that they can just do what they want to do, but avoid sanctions.
‘You have to be able to explain to people why something shouldn’t be done or why there is a better or more correct way of doing it, so they embrace that and go with you, rather than immediately have their heckles put up because you just sound like a rulebook nerd’.
Lutine Bell: Since the crash, are people more now open to compliance?
‘In some circles and some boardrooms, 100%. But equally, the flip side is that some people now use compliance as a way of validating what they want to do, which is equally dangerous.
‘I was in a meeting with somebody – at an unnamed company – and somebody very senior in the business said “we are going to do X, I need you to find a reason in the handbook or through FCA correspondence that will defend the position we are taking if challenged”.
I responded that “it is far better that I give you a view on what your options are, whether they be X or Y, and why I believe that X or Y to be the correct way forward”. But the response was “no, we’ve already made the decision, it will be X, we now need you to be able to support that if challenged”. That is not what compliance is for. Our job is not just to protect the backs of people that work in boardrooms or senior offices so that they can just continue doing what they want to do but avoid any issues. That’s part of the problem since 2008/2009, there is still some of that mentality in boardrooms. “This is what we’ll do, your job is to make sure that we’re safe.” We’re not Trump’s lawyers! We have to be prepared to say ‘you just can’t do that’.
You have to lead from the front, and ultimately, the way you define your culture as a business does permeate into the business.
LB: Does that mentality filter down from the top?
‘Sometimes, because behaviour breeds behaviour. You have to lead from the front, and ultimately, the way you define your culture as a business does permeate down. I have worked in organisations where the people at the coalface will say “that is red on our RAG scale, you can’t do that!” The next person up in the chain of command will say, “I appreciate it’s red, but really it’s not truly red, I think it’s more r-amber”. They turn to their manager and say, “we’ve got this risk that’s somewhere between red and amber…”, and they say “great… personally I think it’s probably amber… but we can get it to green.” And then all the board hears is “it’s green”. That’s because nobody wants to challenge the person above them because they’re thinking about their own career path. The people who have been most successful in my industry are ironically those who in some cases alienated themselves from boards because they have been prepared to challenge.
‘Equally, the best companies I have worked for have been those that have a culture of “I want to do something, but you must tell me if what I am doing is wrong – and I will listen to you!” You might have a little bit of toing and froing, but by and large they do listen to you, and those are the best places to work.
‘There are some people I have worked with, or know through peer groups, that love the confrontation (or if they don’t love it, they are at least not frightened by it), and are very steadfast in their views. You need a degree of that, you must be able to put your position forward if you genuinely think that an outcome could impact a client or end-user. Otherwise, what are you there for, you’re a passenger.
‘That said, I am rubbish at confrontation, I really am terrible. My wife and I joke about it, we say that in the compliance world, when you go into a boardroom your CEO will always have the last word in an argument, and anything compliance says after that point is the start of the next argument, but it doesn’t have to be that way. A willingness to challenge doesn’t come naturally to some people – it doesn’t come naturally to me – and I needed to learn that’.
Dipping into baba ghanoush
‘Some people find it very difficult to differentiate between a business challenge and a personal one. I am one of those people. If I go in with a piece of work and they say “for these reasons this piece of work is terrible”, I will be crestfallen, a little part of me inside dies! All I want is for everyone to think I have done a great job, recognise why I have done it and think compliance is great. However, there is something we do at Saltus which has been a game changer for me.
‘We have an amazing head of people – shout out to Kathryn Kendall – and she is very widely respected for the work that she does developing culture. She did an amazing training session with us which was all about how to encourage trust at board level and how to get the best out of people in order to operate as efficiently as you can. We learnt about the importance of understanding that you can be vulnerable, identify vulnerability within your colleagues, and be able to take open criticism – all things which truly make you effective as a board.
Gloves off, this matters. I’ve got to tell you how it is, because otherwise, this could be an issue. But it’s not personal.
‘In the workshop, we said “well for those of us who aren’t very good at confrontation, how do I know where the conversation is going and know how to respond?” We decided we needed a safe word! Somebody suggested baba ghanoush – like the dip – and it stuck, after all, it’s unlikely to come up in a board meeting otherwise!
‘Now, if you are in a meeting, and you start a conversation with the phrase ‘baba ghanoush’, then the person you are addressing knows immediately that what is about to be said is purely and utterly business, and it’s nothing personal. And it works! We all just understand that when someone says ‘baba ghanoush’, we need to be gloves off, because this comment matters. I’ve got to tell you how it is, because otherwise, this could be an issue – but remember it’s not personal. It’s made a real difference to how open our board meetings are, and how open we are as a senior leadership team.
‘This is only used at board level, because time is so precious. If you’ve got the most senior ten people in a room that’s ten hours of company time between them, so you have to make it count, and you have to get an outcome. I found the pace very difficult when I stepped onto a board for the first time, it was the hardest thing to adjust to.
‘Compliance people by their nature tend to take time to get to a decision, they talk to a lawyer, then someone else in the industry, then their consultancy firm, then they go and have a coffee with somebody else, then they come back with a decision. Even then the decision might or might not be possible. But, on a board you can’t do that and the pace is something that you have to adjust to, so you need baba ghanoush to keep things moving, so to speak!
‘When you’re outside the board situation you have to be more generous with your time. That’s the way to get the best out of people. I mentor a few young people, and with them I make sure to give them an opportunity to say what’s on their mind, and listen to them, and then challenge their thinking and perceptions in a gentle way. It’s different as you’re trying to nurture and grow, as opposed to be functional.
‘When I was at St James’s Place they had a mentoring programme which was really well run. You could put your name done and you would be allocated someone. That’s always nerve wracking, when you put yourself out there as a potential mentor and you worry that nobody wants you, but people do come forward!
‘My daughter has some complex mental health needs and is neurodiverse, and so I started a support group for parents of children with mental health needs, as it can be very hard for parents to get any help. I also mentor some friends of my daughter, who aren’t interested in the finance sector at all – one person wants to go on to do law, another is interested in journalism, which is what my daughter is studying’.
What advice would you give someone looking to move into your sector?
The world of M&A compliance is slightly different to traditional compliance. When a company is up and running and established, or even in a growth phase, then compliance has its place, reacting to the regulator, but ultimately it already knows what it’s looking to do.
It can feel like building the cathedral in Barcelona, it’s never finished! There’s always someone wanting to add another spire.
I liken M&A compliance to building a house. When you’re building a house, compliance would be checking architectural plans, making sure there’s enough builders on site, everything’s running smoothly and the house isn’t going to fall down. The trouble with M&A is that every day you turn up for work and you have a completely different metaphorical building crew and they’ve bought their own plans with them. And then they say, “I know you’ve always done it this way, but have you considered doing it like this?” Sometimes that jars with your business.
‘They have their own identity and their own way of doing things, so you have to work with that, acknowledge and accept it. It can feel like building the cathedral in Barcelona, it’s never finished! There’s always someone wanting to add another spire. That can become a challenge, and take up an inordinate amount of time, trying to ensure that things lock into place smoothly’.
Industry culture
‘There is a change happening. What we do is very highly regulated, and rightly so, and the problem that we face as an industry is that people often criticise the regulator and say that they are too heavy handed, but you have to appreciate the amount of people in the country that have the capacity to screw over a client. It’s important to make sure that doesn’t happen and the client is protected – sometimes from themselves!
‘The regulator has to make certain assumptions around behaviour. It can be very difficult. The sheer volume of work that can come in order to prepare for regulatory change, to turn the ship around and do things slightly differently, can be very stressful. I think as the industry has become more closely policed, that has driven camaraderie because when you’re on the inside, you really feel it.
‘The days of old-style corporate suits that just want to make money come hell or high water regardless of the consequences have now moved on. The newer generation really do care about whether something is ethical and sustainable. They do care about whether clients are getting ripped off. They do want to embrace modern technology. They have got different ways of working.
As the industry has become more closely policed, that has driven camaraderie because when you’re on the inside, you really feel it.
‘I know of someone who was in a meeting and her manager referred to her as ‘the girl on the end with the brown hair’. That’s not just rude, it’s lazy – people’s names are on Teams, so where’s the excuse to not use them? By contrast, I was chatting to our CEO, Tosh, about my daughter’s mental health needs, and about how she was going through a process of diagnosis. He said “there’s a great book you might want to read which might help you as a parent understand a little bit more”. The next day the book arrived at my house. Just from that conversation, he’d bought the book and had it sent to me. That’s the difference in proper culture, living and breathing for your employees. I think there’s a long way to go before we get that everywhere, I think.
‘I really enjoyed working at St James’s Place; the people, their charitable foundation was incredible and there was some great camaraderie. The risk, compliance and financial crime team had a great bond. That team bond is the same at Saltus. The difference is now I am part of a Senior Leadership Team I really feel as though I’m directly contributing to building something special’.
I think culture is driven more by client needs changing and firms embracing that, more so than anything else
‘I spoke to my mum recently, to arrange popping over for a coffee. Mum said “what about on Friday? I’ve got an appointment with the manager at the building society at 10am. We could meet for a coffee afterwards”. And I thought, who still makes appointments with the manager of the building society? Well, clearly my parents’ generation do! But the younger generation doesn’t, and that’s the shift, how people engage with financial services. Everything else follows. I think its driven more by client needs changing and firms embracing that, more so than anything else.’
What challenges do you face most often?
‘M&A compliance is constantly moving, but you have to do things right from day one. Someone who worked for another consolidator said to me that their philosophy was very much get the business on board, and work on corrective measures once they’re on. I likened that to having a hole in your boat – you can fix it in dry dock, and then take it out to sea OR you can fix it at sea. It sounded like they were fixing the boat at sea, but they’d forgotten the tools or materials, and the boat was on fire! Why would you do that? Don’t get me wrong, you can’t stay in dry dock permanently, there’s a point where you have to launch, but you can certainly get things watertight before you take the ship to sea. That all comes back to having a strong compliance team to challenge those things.
‘We don’t bring in a firm if they are not culturally aligned, or if we think that they don’t treat customers the way we want customers to be treated, and if that means we have to spend money on getting that firm properly checked out or ensuring the correct outcomes are being met, we will. Because why would you want to bring in something into camp that could then infect your business?
You can’t procrastinate forever, but you can certainly get thing watertight before you take the ship to sea
‘It makes every day different. You must make sure that nothing goes significantly wrong, that puts you, your business or your clients at risk. The satisfaction comes from getting it right and knowing you’ve done a good job, and that there’s a great outcome for everyone involved, but I won’t sugar-coat it… it’s interesting, but at the same time, that doesn’t always make it fun. Although one of our three mantras that our CEO says is that whatever we do, it has to be fun, and we have to have enjoyed going to work. That’s actually an important thing. When we talk about our strategy and what we stand for, that’s one of the things that’s right in there as our top three. Where you work must be enjoyable!
‘Inclusion is also a big thing we really need to work on, and I say this with a hint of irony – I am after all the very definition of white male privilege. I know and accept that. I would always had said “what do you mean I am privileged, I have had to work hard to get where I am”, but I never really understood what it’s like to not have any barriers. I might have worked hard, but I still had a lot of doors open for me because of my background or my education, my ethnicity or sex.
We really need to try and increase the talent pool, or people to select from, rather than just accepting tokenism
‘There’s still a massive, massive way for us to go on DEI in our industry, massive. But also, social diversity as well, which is considering educational backgrounds, or different starts in life. We really need to try and increase the talent pool, or people to select from, rather than just accepting tokenism, which even the FCA acknowledges is a bad thing. So how do you do that? How do you recognise people? How do you get somebody to think “dammit, I really want to get into financial services compliance! That’s my dream!” how do you get somebody to want that, and then make it interesting enough to get them to go on the journey and then broaden the talent pool. I don’t know the answer, but I think there’s a lot more to be done there.
What keeps you motivated day to day?
‘It sounds like a cliché but its 100% not, it’s my family.
‘My daughter has some additional mental health needs and is neurodiverse. She’s now doing very well, but it’s been hard for her, and us as her family supporting her. Last year was her 21st birthday, and we hired a villa in Tenerife for her and all her friends and paid for them to have a holiday. To be able to give her that and support her and my son in the same way is my true motivation.
‘I know if I do well, and am successful, I can provide those things to my family. The same with my wife, she’s very successful and we do it so that we can provide those moments to our son and daughter – or anyone else within our family – and we can support them. That’s a tremendous gift to be able to have within your control. That’s the biggest motivation, as corny as it sounds’.
What’s your key take-away?
‘Don’t surround yourself with people that will just say yes. You must have people that aren’t afraid to say no to you, and you must allow them to. Otherwise, all that will happen is they will carbon copy what you are doing or reaffirm that what you are doing is brilliant, when actually it might not be brilliant at all. You must have people that will tell you if you aren’t brilliant. And you must listen to them.
If someone is asking for help, they’re asking for a good reason.
‘Also, never take credit for something that you haven’t done. Call out the person who’s done the work or had the idea – give them the credit!
‘Finally, don’t be afraid to ask a question. There have been times during my time at Saltus when I have made an assumption. Our CEO has said to me “baba ghanoush! Why did you make that assumption? Never make a decision that could affect our clients or our company without asking me for help if you need it -i’ll help you. if I’m not helping you, let me know”! Never make a decision on half a piece on information. I suppose the flip of that is – and this comes back to all the people that have helped me and my wife when we’ve needed it as parents – if someone asks you for help, always make time for them. Don’t belittle them for asking.
‘If someone is asking for help, they’re asking for a good reason’.