A Day in the Life of: Clive O’Connell – Partner at McCarthy Denning and Non-Executive Director on multiple boards, a leading authority in insurance and reinsurance law.
Posted on 3rd September 2025
With over four decades of experience, Clive O’Connell, is a specialist in reinsurance, insurance and insurance linked securities, and renowned for his global dispute resolution work.
We took the opportunity to sit down with Clive to hear his thoughts on why the insurance industry often gets a bad rap – and what can be done to shift that perception?
‘Insurance is often sold as a very dull area. It’s not dull, it needn’t be dull. It can be fascinating, provided you develop a fascination.
‘Become fascinated, read around it, look into various aspects of it, take a big picture view as well as looking at the minutiae of the area in which you’re focused. Get excited by it, because it is very exciting’.
We also delved into global instability, regulation and Reform, and heard a little more about Clive’s vision for embedded insurance product to support the developing world.
What advice would you give people who want to move into your sector?
‘I’m a lawyer, but I’m a lawyer who has for the last 43 years been entirely focused on the reinsurance sector. I see myself as being sometimes more of the industry than the profession.
‘The business is incredibly fascinating. It touches upon every aspect of human life and certainly every aspect of commercial life, as well as things that go beyond commerciality, from climate change to wars, absolutely everything. The deeper your fascination with it, the greater your motivation will be to do it well, and the more you will be able to develop ideas about how to tackle the issues that face the industry and its consumers better.
“The deeper your fascination with it, the greater your motivation will be to do it well“
‘Become fascinated, read around it, look into various aspects of it, take a big picture view as well as looking at the minutiae of the area in which you’re focused. Get excited by it, because it is very exciting’.
Lutine Bell: There’s a crossover there with the legal field as well too, I suppose. Both elements with a very human impact?
‘I suppose that can be said for any aspect of life and any aspect of business. Whether you’re working in a corner shop or running a country, you’re impacting upon people. And whichever way one does it, one tries to do it well.
‘In the past, when you spoke to people and you asked them how did you get into insurance, so many people would give the answer ‘I got into it by accident’. I asked the question once to the Claims Director of a large mutual insurer, and his answer was much better, he said ‘I wanted to do good, and I wanted to help people when problems beset them’. I like the answer because it’s talking about what insurance actually does and it’s talking about what insurers do, which is to pay claims when people need them, not to hide behind small print and fight every claim. It is to make sure that claims that are properly payable are paid swiftly and efficiently and the maximum benefit given to those who need it.
LB: People don’t always think of the finance sector as an area that people move into when they want to help people, but phrasing it like that, it’s exactly what it is…
‘Some years ago, I was talking to Joan Lamm-Tennant, a pioneer in micro insurance, and a professor at Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. She told me that you could tell with their students who were studying insurance, something happened when they learned about micro insurance, because suddenly they got interested and excited.
“Insurance is there to do good. One must keep that in mind”.
‘Micro insurance is a subject which is exciting because it could be transformative of the way in which the world works and could do immeasurable good. But at the same time, it also shows how normal insurance helps. It’s perhaps starker when you’re seeing it on a micro level, but when you’re looking at it in the developed world, in sophisticated models, the same amount of good can also be done. I think that is a really important element to insurance. Insurance is there to do good. One must keep that in mind’.
LB: Is that message communicated well enough to people looking to move into the industry?
‘Some organisations do and some don’t.
‘For many years I was an active participant in the International Insurance Society and I was on the board and the Pro-Bono General Counsel. At many of their talks you would hear from leaders in the industry, and they had people from all around the world speaking amazingly well about the impact that insurance can have and how it can really help the world, whereas others would simply talk about return on investment.
‘I remember one year that we had an amazing speech by a keynote speech on the first day of the conference from a Japanese CEO, who talked about the power of insurance to do good. The next day, somebody who hadn’t been there for the first day turned up to give another keynote speech. He spoke about how to drive return on investment for shareholders. He completely missed the feel of the room because people have been so impressed by what was said the day before.
“The role of a Non-Exec Director is to look after all the stakeholders in the company, not just the shareholders“
‘ROI is of course an important element, but it’s not the only element. The role of a Non-Exec Director is to look after all the stakeholders in the company, not just the shareholders, but all of the stakeholders – the employees, the customers, the regulator, creditors – the whole lot. One way you do that is you make sure that the company is profitable, because then everybody is looked after. But at the same time, it’s important to always know that there are things other than just the ROI that one has to look to.
‘In the immediate aftermath of the financial crash of 2008, BBC Radio 4’s Today program did a vox pop walking around the City of London. One of the people they stopped was a banker and he was asked, so what went wrong? And he said ‘bankers forgot what they were there for’. Banks are there provide capital and help businesses flourish. What banks started to do, and what bankers within them started to do, was to look to maximise their bonuses, their team profitability, the bank’s profitability. They were spinning deal after deal, looking just at the margins that they could make off those deals and not looking at the underlying good.
‘I think he made a very good point and it’s something that came up in the reinsurance industry in particular back in the 1980s when we had the LMX spiral, where we saw underwriting agents and brokers – all people paid on commission – turning business around and around so that the ultimate risk taker got very little risk premium. Just about everything was paid in premium by the underlying insured, and that almost caused the end of Lloyd’s in the London market.
LB: So, is it still the case that relatively few people are able to drive potential chaos or has regulation smoothed the waters?
‘It can be down to just a few people manipulating markets. It was illustrated well by the film, the Big Short. ‘It didn’t take many people to create something which had a devastating effect on hundreds of millions, if not billions of people. And the impact of which we are still feeling today, not just economically, but politically as well.
What skills do you feel are key to success?
‘What one needs is interpersonal skills. You need to be able to understand people, communicate with them and motivate them as well.
“Interpersonal skills are absolutely vital for, well, any job that I’ve ever had.”
‘Interpersonal skills are absolutely vital for, well, any job that I’ve ever had. I’m sure that there are some people who may not have those skills who do very well sitting, crunching numbers or writing dry tomes of text. But interpersonal skills are just absolutely key for this role’.
What key challenges do you face in your role?
‘The challenges I face as a lawyer are always trying to explain to clients that it is sometimes the law is not what they want the law to be. We have to do things in a way that fits into the law.
‘We work in an industry where the law was largely laid down in the Victorian era, if not before. Regulation has been formed by issues that affected the market in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s and maybe into the 2000s, but not much after that, yet there is such innovation! Innovation in the nature of the risk that needs to be covered, innovation in challenges coming from competitors in the capital markets, all sorts of things.
“Sometimes the law is not what they want the law to be“.
‘People are trying to develop new products, but they have to fit into the framework of the law and the regulation that already exists, sometimes the challenge is to try and take the new product and fit that round peg into the square hole of the existing legal and regulatory infrastructure.
‘The other challenge is, and this is one of the great benefits of being old, is that sometimes some of these terribly innovative products are exactly what we saw 40 years ago. However, one is able to look at them, analyse them, explain where the problems lie and try to find solutions to them!
LB: Would some of the changes be easier to have if the relationship between regulator and industry was on a more even keel?
‘I think that the regulators and the regulated have massive challenges and we have seen an incredible growth in the amount of regulation.
“The challenge is to try and take a new product and fit that round peg into the square hole of existing legal and regulatory infrastructure”.
‘I remember in the mid to late 90s, going down to Lloyd’s with an active underwriter from a Lloyd syndicate to see the regulatory department there. We were kept waiting in the reception area for a particularly long time because that’s the way that they operated! While we were there, we mused that there were pictures on the wall of everyone in the regulatory departments, and upon counting them up we realised that there were then more people in the regulatory department at Lloyds than there were active underwriters in Lloyds.
‘That was quite shocking, at the time. If you were there today, there would be multiple times more regulators than there are syndicates at Lloyd’s, and no one would even question it. But in those days, if you had one compliance officer in a Lloyds agency, that was a lot!
The way in which we’ve come to deal with regulation has changed, but it also means that the people involved in regulation are changing considerably as well.
“People often point to UK regulation as the gold standard. However, compared with many other jurisdictions, the regulator isn’t as approachable”.
People often point to UK regulation as the gold standard. However, compared with many other jurisdictions, the regulator isn’t as approachable. Quite often you go along to a meeting with a regulator, and then you go to one six weeks later and its completely different people. You’re having to explain the same commercial reality all over again. Coupled with the fact that the shelf life of a regulator typically isn’t that long… they move on quickly, many good ones get headhunted by the large accountancy practices, insurers or banks. This leaves you with a situation where you find that there are very few people with an in-depth knowledge of the markets, and that creates problem because they don’t necessarily understand the commercial reality, they look at the black and white of the regulation rather than the intent of the regulation.
What does the future hold?
LB: With so much instability globally that is clearly is taking up bandwidth, surely having some stability at home would be helpful. How is the sector dealing with that?
‘We need some form of stability. Since Brexit, we have faced the potential of a massive increase in regulation. I know Brexit was meant to be a bonfire of regulation, but it just can’t be.
‘In the insurance sector we work in a global business and therefore someone operating in London has to abide by US regulation if they want to trade there. They have to operate under EU regulation, and they’ll have to operate under UK regulation as well. So, moving away from Solvency II will add to, rather than subtract from the regulatory burden. The only people who will benefit by such a move, and they deserve to benefit, I would add, could potentially be people like purely domestic mutuals who need relief from the capital requirements of Solvency II. Brexit could be an opportunity for them to be absolved from that, but I think for most other players in the market, it’s going to create just more regulation.
“Heavyweight regulatory frameworks don’t allow anyone to go bust, but at the same time they don’t allow anyone to succeed overly”.
‘If Reform form a government in four years’ time, maybe they will slash all regulations, but they have to be very careful of doing that because if they do that, the reputation of UK business could suffer enormously. We’ve seen Bermuda, Switzerland, Japan all go onto equal footings with Solvency II, with equivalence. We’ve got the US operating under an almost equivalent system to Solvency II. If we step away from that, we don’t become Singapore-on-Thames, we become more like a distant tropical tax haven in terms of our regulatory standards. A dangerous move, as the regulatory standards in the UK are something that does attract business here.
LB: Surely playing fast and loose with financial regulations will only lead to a regulatory hokey-cokey, for organisations when the next government reinstates them all?
‘I don’t think we can predict anything in today’s political world, but if someone like Reform does come in, they would take a sledgehammer to as much of the infrastructure as they possibly can and make it almost impossible to rebuild it, or rebuild it within a relatively short period of time. There’ll need to be a lot of reconstruction afterwards.
“If we step away from regulation, we won’t become Singapore-on-Thames, we become more like a distant tropical tax haven in terms of our regulatory standards”.
‘What the American government has done with DOGE is to rip apart infrastructure, and I suspect that’s what will happen here, and we’ll have to see how we can cope with that. One thing that does concern me is yes, there’s many aspects of regulation which have gone too far, but one has to be careful of what one dreams for, because when you start reducing regulation, you have to do it extremely carefully to make sure you don’t take away the safeguards that we need both for consumer protection and for the integrity of the market.
‘Frank Borman – the Commander of Apollo 8 – went on to be the CEO of United Airlines, a company that went bust. He once said beautifully that “capitalism without bankruptcy is like Christianity without hell”. One problem with very heavyweight regulatory frameworks such as Solvency II is that they do not allow anyone to go bust, but at the same time they don’t allow anyone to succeed overly. You stick everybody into a band of mediocrity.
“Many aspects of regulation have gone too far, but one has to be careful of what one dreams of, because when you start reducing it, you have to do it extremely carefully“.
‘One has to think about what one’s tolerance is for failure. What safeguards can one put in place to protect those who might be affected by failure? It’s a difficult thing and it’s concept it’s not just conceptually difficult, it’s also politically difficult because then one has to look at to what extent do you want the state to intervene to make good the damage done by commercial – quite often international – companies? And to what extent should state resources be used in order to step in and pay off policyholders if there is a failure?
LB: It’s an orchestrated version of reality, isn’t it? Realistically, failure is part of life.
‘But what is happening at the moment is there is a lot of innovation going on and there’s a lot of challenges happening to the status quo. Insurtech and other things are really ramping up quite quickly, so it will be interesting to see how those challenges affect the more traditional insurers and reinsurers out there. ‘Are the existing insurers going to move quickly enough to stop those gaps and stop challenges coming in to take away their business? And the other side of this, and this is the bit that gets me excited, is that if you are doing something innovative and challenging in the insurance industry, why are you fighting for UK motor business or household business? Because there’s a lot of risk out there, a lot of new risk out there. There’s a lot of existing risk that has never been insured out there. Why aren’t you fighting for those markets? And this, perhaps this brings me on to what is my dream job scenario…’
What job would you be doing if you weren’t doing yours?
‘What I would dearly love to do is to get an insurance concern off the ground that provides embedded parametric insurance to protect people in the developing world against the impact of natural disasters.
‘I think if one could achieve that, one could do so much good in the world – you would bring insurance to people who not only don’t have insurance, but who need it more than anyone else.
‘Looking down my street in central London – with all the bankers and hedge fund managers and lawyers who live here – if one of their houses burnt down and they didn’t have insurance, they would be able to find accommodation and they’d be able to look after themselves.
‘If you’re in the developing world and your home is flooded and your only goat is killed, and your crops are swept away… you’re destitute and you’ve got nothing. And despite what Joni Mitchell said, freedom isn’t just another word for nothing left to lose. No. That’s destitution, and it’s not a good thing. But insurance has the ability to protect against that.
We know that people in the developing world think of insurance in exactly the same way that people in the developed world think of insurance, that all insurers are money-grabbing thieves who don’t pay claims and rely on small print. The great thing about an embedded product is that you get over the reluctance to purchase.
“Freedom isn’t just another word for nothing left to lose. No. That’s destitution, and it’s not a good thing”.
If an insurance product costs even a few cents, people are more likely to want to spend that money on food, or clothing for their children than they would on an insurance product. But if you embed it, people then have the insurance without considering it. You embed it in something else. There was a project a while ago where seed grain crop failure insurance was included in the price of seed grain. If the crops failed, the insurance paid out, so the policyholder wasn’t any worse off than if the crops succeeded.
Embedding a product in a service such as a mobile phone tariff – people throughout the world have mobile phones now – would allow you to cover a huge number of people very easily. The technology is currently there to do this, and using mobile telephony, the ability to pay claims quickly is there. With parametric claims, they can be paid the moment a disaster happens, so when a disaster hits an area, money floods straight into the individuals via their mobile phones.
On a microeconomic basis, this would do an immense amount of good, directly helping the economy of that region, rather than frustrating the economic growth of that area. For me, this is potentially the most exciting thing that insurance can do. It means challenging the existing insurance market, by going out and providing something very different to people who really need it. If you want a dream job, that’s what I’d like to be doing!
LB: What would you need to help you move your dream into a reality?
‘One of the reasons for developing such a product is to ingrain insurance into the minds of people. What studies on micro insurance have seen is that with most projects you expect to have a 200% loss ratio in the first year and therefore you need a lot of charitable seed capital to go in to start the project off.
However, what will happen in those projects is that the people who make claims and the friends and families of those who make claims will be very good customers for the future policyholders of the future. If you do an embedded product, you’re not looking to encourage them to renewed because they’re going to be renewing automatically.
But when a claim is paid, the mindset about insurance starts to change. The mentality of ‘oh, I could spend a little bit more money and buy additional cover’ starts to develop, and that’s when you start to generate an insurance economy’.
What is your career takeaway?
‘I think that the one liner to live by throughout one’s career is integrity. If you lose your integrity, you have nothing.
“If you lose your integrity, you have nothing”.
‘Be true to your integrity, maintain it and always be decent. Look at the long-term advantages of decency rather than the short-term advantages of not being decent. ‘To me, that’s it. I suppose maybe it comes from my age and my position in my career that it’s easier to look back and think, yes, that’s the one thing I really want. It doesn’t matter how much money I’ve earned or anything. None of that’s worth anything if you haven’t kept your integrity’.